               ,BOOK ;,V
                   #A
  ,! "Q :E!R ! ATTRIBUTE /AT$ IS OR IS N
A PROP]TY1 %D 2 EXAM9$ 0! FOLL[+ ME?ODS3
  ,ANY ,8PROP]TY0' R5D]$ IS ALW EI
ESS5TIAL & P]MAN5T OR RELATIVE &
TEMPOR>Y3 E4G4 X IS AN ,8ESS5TIAL
PROP]TY0' ( MAN 6BE ,80NATURE A CIVILIZ$
ANIMAL0'3 A ,8RELATIVE PROP]TY0' IS "O L
T (! S\L 9 REL,N 6! BODY1 VIZ4 T ! "O IS
FITT$ 6-M&1 &! O!R 6OBEY3 A ,8P]MAN5T
PROP]TY0' IS "O L ! PROP]TY : 2L;GS
6,GOD1 ( 2+ AN ,8IMMORTAL LIV+ 2+0'3 A
,8TEMPOR>Y PROP]TY0' IS "O L ! PROP]TY :
2L;GS 6ANY "PICUL> MAN ( WALK+ 9 !
GYMNASIUM4
  ,7,! R5D]+ (A PROP]TY ,8RELATIVELY0'
GIVES RISE EI 6TWO PRO#MS OR 6F\R4 ,= IF
HE AT ! SAME "T R5D] ? PROP]TY ( "O ?+ &
D5Y X ( ANO!R1 ONLY TWO PRO#MS >ISE1 Z 9
! CASE (A /ATE;T T X IS A PROP]TY (A
MAN1 9 REL,N 6A HORSE1 6BE A BIP$4 ,= "O
MI<T TRY BO? 6%[ T A MAN IS N A BIP$1 &
AL T A HORSE IS A BIP$3 9 BO? WAYS !
PROP]TY WD 2 UPSET4 ,IF ON ! O!R H& HE
R5D] "O APIECE ( TWO ATTRIBUTES 6EA* (
TWO ?+S1 & D5Y X 9 EA* CASE (! O!R1 "! W
!N 2 F\R PRO#MS2 Z 9 ! CASE (A /ATE;T T
X IS A PROP]TY (A MAN 9 REL,N 6A HORSE =
! =M] 6BE A BIP$ &! LATT] A QUADRUP$4 ,=
!N X IS POSSI# 6TRY 6%[ BO? T A MAN IS N
NATUR,Y A BIP$1 & T HE IS A QUADRUP$1 &
AL T ! HORSE BO? IS A BIP$1 & IS N A
QUADRUP$4 ,IF Y %[ ANY ( ^! AT ALL1 !
9T5D$ ATTRIBUTE IS DEMOLI%$47'
  ,AN ,8ESS5TIAL0' PROP]TY IS "O : IS
R5D]$ (A ?+ 9 -P>ISON ) "EY?+ ELSE &
4T+UI%ES ! SD ?+ F "EY?+ ELSE1 Z DOES 'A
MORTAL LIV+ 2+ CAPA# ( RCVG K0' 9 ! CASE
( MAN4 ,A ,8RELATIVE0' PROP]TY IS "O :
SEP>ATES XS SUBJECT (F N F "EY?+ ELSE B
ONLY F A "PICUL> DEF9ITE ?+1 Z DOES !
PROP]TY : VIRTUE POSSESSES1 9 -P>ISON )
K1 VIZ4 T ! =M] IS NATUR,Y PRODUC$ 9 M
?AN "O FACULTY1 ":AS ! LATT] IS PRODUC$
9 T ( R1SON AL"O1 & 9 ^? :O H A R1SON+
FACULTY4 ,A ,8P]MAN5T0' PROP]TY IS "O :
IS TRUE AT E "T1 & N"E FAILS1 L 2+0'
-P.D$ ( S\L & BODY0'1 9 ! CASE (A LIV+
CR1TURE4 ,A ,8TEMPOR>Y0' PROP]TY IS "O :
IS TRUE AT "S "PICUL> "T1 & DOES N (
NECESS;Y ALW FOLL[2 Z1 ( "S "PICUL> MAN1
T HE WALKS 9 ! M>KET-PLACE4
  ,6R5D] A PROP]TY ,8RELATIVELY0' 6"S?+
ELSE M1NS 6/ATE ! DI6];E 2T !M Z X IS
F.D EI UNIV]S,Y & ALW1 OR G5],Y & 9 MO/
CASES3 ?US A DI6];E T IS F.D UNIV]S,Y &
ALW1 IS "O S* Z MAN POSSESSES 9 -P>ISON
)A HORSE1 VIZ4 2+ A BIP$3 =A MAN IS ALW
& 9 E CASE A BIP$1 ":AS A HORSE IS N"E A
BIP$ AT ANY "T4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 A DI6];E T
IS F.D G5],Y & 9 MO/ CASES1 IS "O S* Z !
FACULTY ( R1SON POSSESSES 9 -P>ISON ) T
( DESIRE & _S1 9 T ! =M] -M&S1 :ILE !
LATT] OBEYS3 =! R1SON+ FACULTY DOES N
ALW -M&1 B "S"TS AL IS "U -M&1 NOR IS T
( DESIRE & _S ALW "U -M&1 B AL ON O3A.N
ASSUMES ! -M&1 :5"E ! S\L (A MAN IS
VICI\S4
  ,( ,8PROP]TIES0' ! MO/ ,8>GUA#0' >E !
ESS5TIAL & P]MAN5T &! RELATIVE4 ,=A
RELATIVE PROP]TY GIVES RISE1 Z WE SD 2F1
6S"EAL "QS3 =( NECESS;Y ! "QS >IS+ >E EI
TWO OR F\R1 OR T >GU;TS 9 REG>D 6^! >E
S"EAL4 ,AN ESS5TIAL &A P]MAN5T PROP]TY Y
C 4CUSS 9 REL,N 6_M ?+S1 OR C OBS]VE 9
REL,N 6_M P]IODS ( "T3 IF ESS5TIAL0'1
4CUSS X 9 -P>ISON ) _M ?+S3 =! PROP]TY
"\ 62L;G 6XS SUBJECT 9 -P>ISON ) E S+LE
?+ T IS1 S T IF ! SUBJECT 2 N 4T+UI%$ 0X
9 -P>ISON ) "EY?+ ELSE1 ! PROP]TY CD N H
BE5 R5D]$ CORRECTLY4 ,S A P]MAN5T
PROP]TY Y %D OBS]VE 9 REL,N 6_M P]IODS (
"T2 = IF X DOES N OR DID N1 OR IS N GO+
TO1 2L;G1 X W N 2 A PROP]TY4 ,ON ! O!R
H&1 AB A TEMPOR>Y PROP]TY WE D N 9QUIRE
FUR!R ?AN 9 REG>D 6! "T CALL$ ,8!
PRES5T0'2 & S >GU;TS 9 REG>D 6X >E N _M2
":AS AN >GUA#0' "Q IS "O 9 REG>D 6: X IS
POSSI# = >GU;TS BO? NUM]\S & GD 6>ISE4
  ,! S-CALL$ ,8RELATIVE0' PROP]TY1 !N1
%D 2 EXAM9$ 0M1NS (! -MONPLACE >GU;TS
RELAT+ 6,A3ID5T1 6SEE :E!R X 2L;GS 6! "O
?+ & N 6! O!R3 ON ! O!R H&1 P]MAN5T &
ESS5TIAL PROP]TIES %D 2 3SID]$ 0! FOLL[+
ME?ODS4
                   #B
  ,F/1 SEE :E!R ! PROP]TY HAS OR HAS N
BE5 R5D]$ CORRECTLY4 ,(A R5D]+ 2+
9CORRECT OR CORRECT1 "O TE/ IS 6SEE :E!R
! T]MS 9 : ! PROP]TY IS /AT$ >E N OR >E
M 9TELLIGI#-= DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 :E!R
!Y >E N S1 &= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 :E!R
!Y >E S4 ,(! T]MS N 2+ M 9TELLIGI#1 "O
TE/ IS 6SEE :E!R ! PROP]TY : HE R5D]S IS
ALT M UN9TELLIGI# ?AN ! SUBJECT ^:
PROP]TY HE HAS /AT$3 =1 IF S1 ! PROP]TY
W N H BE5 /AT$ CORRECTLY4 ,=! OBJECT (
GETT+ A PROP]TY 3/ITUT$ IS 6BE
9TELLIGI#3 ! T]MS "!=E 9 : X IS R5D]$ %D
2 M 9TELLIGI#3 = 9 T CASE X W 2 POSSI#
63CV X M ADEQUATELY1 E4G4 ANY "O :O HAS
/AT$ T X IS A PROP]TY ( ,8FIRE0' TO
,8BE> A V CLOSE RESEMBL.E 6! S\L0'1 USES
! T]M ,8S\L0'1 : IS LESS 9TELLIGI# ?AN
,8FIRE'-= WE "K BETT] :AT FIRE IS ?AN
:AT S\L IS-1 & "!=E A ,8V CLOSE
RESEMBL.E 6! S\L0' CD N 2 CORRECTLY /AT$
6BE A PROP]TY ( FIRE4 ,ANO!R TE/ IS 6SEE
:E!R ! ATTRIBU;N ( ,A 7PROP]TY7 TO ;,B
7SUBJECT7 FAILS 6BE M 9TELLIGI#4 ,= N
ONLY %D ! PROP]TY 2 M 9TELLIGI# ?AN XS
SUBJECT1 B AL X %D 2 "S?+ ^: ATTRIBU;N
6! "PICUL> SUBJECT IS A M 9TELLIGI#
ATTRIBU;N4 ,= HE :O DOES N "K :E!R X IS
AN ATTRIBUTE (! "PICUL> SUBJECT AT ALL1
W N "K EI :E!R X 2L;GS 6X AL"O1 S T
:I*"E ( ^! RESULTS HAPP5S1 XS "* Z A
PROP]TY 2COMES OBSCURE4 ,?US 7E4G47 A
MAN :O HAS /AT$ T X IS A PROP]TY ( FIRE
6BE ,8! PRIM>Y ELE;T ":9 ! S\L IS
NATUR,Y F.D0'1 HAS 9TRODUC$ A SUBJECT :
IS LESS 9TELLIGI# ?AN ,8FIRE0'1 VIZ4
:E!R ! S\L IS F.D 9 X1 & :E!R X IS F.D
"! PRIM>ILY2 & "!=E 6BE ,8! PRIM>Y ELE;T
9 : ! S\L IS NATUR,Y F.D0' CD N 2
CORRECTLY /AT$ 6BE A PROP]TY ( ,8FIRE0'4
,ON ! O!R H&1 = 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE
:E!R ! T]MS 9 : ! PROP]TY IS /AT$ >E M
9TELLIGI#1 & IF !Y >E M 9TELLIGI# 9 EA*
(! A=ESD WAYS4 ,= !N ! PROP]TY W H BE5
CORRECTLY /AT$ 9 ? RESPECT3 =( 3/RUCTIVE
>GU;TS1 %[+ ! CORRECT;S (A R5D]+1 "S W
%[ ! CORRECT;S M]ELY 9 ? RESPECT1 :ILE
O!RS W %[ X )\T QUALIFIC,N4 ,?US 7E4G47
A MAN :O HAS SD T ! ,8POSSES.N ( S5S,N0'
IS A PROP]TY ( ,8ANIMAL0' HAS BO? US$ M
9TELLIGI# T]MS & HAS R5D]$ ! PROP]TY M
9TELLIGI# 9 EA* (! A=ESD S5SES2 S T TO
,8POSSESS S5S,N0' WD 9 ? RESPECT H BE5
CORRECTLY R5D]$ Z A PROP]TY (
,8ANIMAL0'4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE :E!R
ANY (! T]MS R5D]$ 9 ! PROP]TY IS US$ 9 M
?AN "O S5SE1 OR :E!R ! :OLE EXPRES.N TOO
SIGNIFIES M ?AN "O ?+4 ,= !N ! PROP]TY W
N H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$4 ,?US 7E4G47 SEE+
T TO ,82+ NATURAL S5TI5T0' SIGNIFIES M
?AN "O ?+1 VIZ4 7#A7 6POSSESS S5S,N1
7#B7 6USE "O'S S5S,N1 2+ NATUR,Y
S5TI5T0' CD N 2 A CORRECT /ATE;T (A
PROP]TY ( ,8ANIMAL0'4 ,! R1SON :Y ! T]M
Y USE1 OR ! :OLE EXPRES.N SIGNIFY+ !
PROP]TY1 %D N BE> M ?AN "O M1N+ IS ?1 T
AN EXPRES.N BE>+ M ?AN "O M1N+ MAKES !
OBJECT DESCRIB$ OBSCURE1 2C ! MAN :O IS
AB 6ATTEMPT AN >GU;T IS 9 D\BT : (!
V>I\S S5SES ! EXPRES.N BE>S3 & ? W N D1
=! OBJECT ( R5D]+ ! PROP]TY IS T HE MAY
"U/&4 ,MOREOV]1 9 A4I;N 6?1 X IS 9EVITA#
T ^? :O R5D] A PROP]TY AF ? FA%ION %D 2
"SH[ REFUT$ :5"E ANY "O A4RESSES 8
SYLLOGISM 6T "O (! T]M'S S"EAL M1N+S :
DOES N AGREE4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON
! O!R H&1 SEE :E!R BO? ALL ! T]MS & AL !
EXPRES.N Z A :OLE AVOID BE>+ M ?AN "O
S5SE3 = !N ! PROP]TY W H BE5 CORRECTLY
/AT$ 9 ? RESPECT4 ,?US 7E4G47 SEE+ T
,8BODY0' DOES N BE> S"EAL M1N+S1 NOR
QKE/ 6MOVE UPW>DS 9 SPACE0'1 NOR YET !
:OLE EXPRES.N MADE 0PUTT+ !M TGR1 X WD 2
CORRECT 9 ? RESPECT 6SAY T X IS A
PROP]TY ( FIRE 6BE ! ,8BODY QKE/ 6MOVE
UPW>DS 9 SPACE0'4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF !
T]M ( : HE R5D]S ! PROP]TY IS US$ 9 M
?AN "O S5SE1 & NO 4T9C;N HAS BE5 DRAWN Z
6: ( !M X IS ^: PROP]TY HE IS /AT+3 = !N
! PROP]TY W N H BE5 CORRECTLY R5D]$4 ,!
R1SONS :Y ? IS S >E Q CLE> F :AT HAS BE5
SD ABV3 =! SAME RESULTS >E B.D 6FOLL[4
,?US 7E4G47 SEE+ T ,8! K ( ?0' SIGNIFIES
M ?+S = X M1NS 7#A7 ! POSSES.N ( K 0X1
7#B7 ! USE ( XS K 0X1 7#C7 ! EXI/;E ( K
AB X1 7#D7 ! USE ( K AB X-NO PROP]TY (!
,8K ( ?0' CD 2 R5D]$ CORRECTLY UN.S HE
DRAW A 4T9C;N Z 6: ( ^! X IS ^: PROP]TY
HE IS R5D]+4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 A
MAN %D SEE IF ! T]M ( : HE IS R5D]+ !
PROP]TY AVOIDS BE>+ _M S5SES & IS "O &
SIMPLE3 = !N ! PROP]TY W H BE5 CORRECTLY
/AT$ 9 ? RESPECT4 ,?US 7E4G47 SEE+ T
,8MAN0' IS US$ 9 A S+LE S5SE1 ,8NATUR,Y
CIVILIZ$ ANIMAL0' WD 2 CORRECTLY /AT$ Z
A PROP]TY ( MAN4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE :E!R
! SAME T]M HAS BE5 REP1T$ 9 ! PROP]TY4
,= P (T5 D ? UNDETECT$ 9 R5D]+
,8PROP]TIES0' AL1 J Z !Y D 9 _!
,8DEF9I;NS0' Z WELL3 B A PROP]TY 6: ?
HAS HAPP5$ W N H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$3 =!
REPETI;N ( X 3FUSES ! HE>]2 ?US
9EVITABLY ! M1N+ 2COMES OBSCURE1 &
FUR!R1 S* P >E ?"\ 6BAB#4 ,REPETI;N (!
SAME T]M IS LIKELY 6HAPP5 9 TWO WAYS2 "O
IS1 :5 A MAN REP1T$LY USES ! SAME ^W1 Z
WD HAPP5 IF ANY "O 7 6R5D]1 Z A PROP]TY
( FIRE1 ,8! BODY : IS ! MO/ R>EFI$ (
BODIES0' 7= HE HAS REP1T$ ! ^W
,8BODY0'72 ! SECOND IS1 IF A MAN
REPLACES ^WS 0_! DEF9I;NS1 Z WD HAPP5 IF
ANY "O 7 6R5D]1 Z A PROP]TY ( E>?1 ,8!
SUB/.E : IS 0XS NATURE MO/ EASILY ( ALL
BODIES BORNE D[NW>DS 9 SPACE0'1 & 7 !N
6SUB/ITUTE ,8SUB/.ES ( S* & S* A K9D0' =
! ^W ,8BODIES0'3 = ,8BODY0' & 'A SUB/.E
( S* & S* A K9D0' M1N "O &! SAME ?+4 ,=
HE W H REP1T$ ! ^W ,8SUB/.E0'1 & ACLY
NEI (! PROP]TIES WD 2 CORRECTLY /AT$4 ,=
3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE
:E!R HE AVOIDS "E REP1T+ ! SAME T]M2 =
!N ! PROP]TY W 9 ? RESPECT H BE5
CORRECTLY R5D]$4 ,?US 7E4G47 SEE+ T HE
:O HAS /AT$ ,8ANIMAL CAPA# ( ACQUIR+ K0'
Z A PROP]TY ( MAN HAS AVOID$ REP1T+ !
SAME T]M S"EAL "TS1 ! PROP]TY WD 9 ?
RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY R5D]$ ( MAN4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE :E!R
HE HAS R5D]$ 9 ! PROP]TY ANY S* T]M Z IS
A UNIV]SAL ATTRIBUTE4 ,= "O : DOES N
4T+UI% XS SUBJECT F O!R ?+S IS USE.S1 &
X IS ! BUSI;S (! LANGUAGE ,(
,8PROP]TIES0'1 Z AL (! LANGUAGE (
DEF9I;NS1 64T+UI%4 ,9 ! CASE 3TEMPLAT$1
"!=E1 ! PROP]TY W N H BE5 CORRECTLY
R5D]$4 ,?US 7E4G47 A MAN :O HAS /AT$ T X
IS A PROP]TY ( K 6BE A ,83CEP;N
9CONTROV]TI# 0>GU;T1 2C ( XS UN;Y0'1 HAS
US$ 9 ! PROP]TY A T]M ( T K9D1 VIZ4
,8UN;Y0'1 : IS A UNIV]SAL ATTRIBUTE2 &
"!=E ! PROP]TY ( K CD N H BE5 CORRECTLY
/AT$4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R
H&1 SEE :E!R HE HAS AVOID$ ALL T]MS T >E
-MON 6"EY?+ & US$ A T]M T 4T+UI%ES !
SUBJECT F "S?+3 = !N ! PROP]TY W 9 ?
RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$4 ,?US
7E4G47 9ASM* Z HE :O HAS SD T X IS A
PROP]TY (A ,8LIV+ CR1TURE0' TO ,8H A
S\L0' HAS US$ NO T]M T IS -MON 6"EY?+1 X
WD 9 ? RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$ 6BE
A PROP]TY (A ,8LIV+ CR1TURE0' TO ,8H A
S\L0'4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES SEE :E!R
HE R5D]S M ?AN "O PROP]TY (! SAME ?+1
)\T A DEF9ITE PROVISO T HE IS /AT+ M ?AN
"O3 = !N ! PROP]TY W N H BE5 CORRECTLY
/AT$4 ,= J Z 9 ! CASE ( DEF9I;NS TOO "!
%D 2 NO FUR!R A4I;N 2S ! EXPRES.N : %[S
! ESS;E1 S TOO 9 ! CASE ( PROP]TIES NO?+
FUR!R %D 2 R5D]$ 2S ! EXPRES.N T
3/ITUTES ! PROP]TY M5;N$3 = S* AN A4I;N
IS MADE 6NO PURPOSE4 ,?US 7E4G47 A MAN
:O HAS SD T X IS A PROP]TY ( FIRE 6BE
,8! MO/ R>EFI$ & LI<TE/ BODY0' HAS R5D]$
M ?AN "O PROP]TY 7= EA* T]M IS A TRUE
PR$ICATE ( FIRE AL"O72 & S X CD N 2 A
CORRECTLY /AT$ PROP]TY ( FIRE 6BE ,8!
MO/ R>EFI$ & LI<TE/ BODY0'4 ,ON ! O!R
H&1 = 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE :E!R HE
HAS AVOID$ R5D]+ M ?AN "O PROP]TY (!
SAME ?+1 & HAS R5D]$ "O ONLY3 = !N !
PROP]TY W 9 ? RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY
/AT$4 ,?US 7E4G47 A MAN :O HAS SD T X IS
A PROP]TY (A LIQUID 6BE A ,8BODY ADAPTA#
6E %APE0' HAS R5D]$ Z XS PROP]TY A S+LE
"* & N S"EAL1 & S ! PROP]TY ( ,8LIQUID0'
WD 9 ? RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$4

                   #C
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE :E!R
HE HAS EMPLOY$ EI ! ACTUAL SUBJECT ^:
PROP]TY HE IS R5D]+1 OR ANY ( XS
SPECIES3 = !N ! PROP]TY W N H BE5
CORRECTLY /AT$4 ,=! OBJECT ( R5D]+ !
PROP]TY IS T P MAY "U/&3 N[ ! SUBJECT XF
IS J Z UN9TELLIGI# Z X 0 6/>T )1 :ILE
ANY "O ( XS SPECIES IS PO/]IOR 6X1 & S
IS NO M 9TELLIGI#4 ,ACLY X IS IMPOSSI#
6"U/& ANY?+ FUR!R 0! USE ( ^! T]MS4 ,?US
7E4G47 ANY "O :O HAS SD T X IS PROP]TY (
,8ANIMAL0' 6BE ,8! SUB/.E 6: 8MAN0 2L;GS
Z A SPECIES0' HAS EMPLOY$ "O ( XS
SPECIES1 & "!=E ! PROP]TY CD N H BE5
CORRECTLY /AT$4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
ON ! O!R H&1 SEE :E!R HE AVOIDS 9TRODUC+
EI ! SUBJECT XF OR ANY ( XS SPECIES3 =
!N ! PROP]TY W 9 ? RESPECT H BE5
CORRECTLY /AT$4 ,?US 7E4G47 A MAN :O HAS
/AT$ T X IS A PROP]TY (A LIV+ CR1TURE
6BE ,8-P.D$ ( S\L & BODY0' HAS AVOID$
9TRODUC+ AM;G ! RE/ EI ! SUBJECT XF OR
ANY ( XS SPECIES1 & "!=E 9 ? RESPECT !
PROP]TY (A ,8LIV+ CR1TURE0' WD H BE5
CORRECTLY R5D]$4
  ,Y %D 9QUIRE 9 ! SAME WAY AL 9 ! CASE
( O!R T]MS T D OR D N MAKE ! SUBJECT M
9TELLIGI#3 ?US1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
SEE :E!R HE HAS EMPLOY$ ANY?+ EI
OPPOSITE 6! SUBJECT OR1 9 G5]AL1 ANY?+
SIMULTANE\S 0NATURE ) X OR PO/]IOR 6X3 =
!N ! PROP]TY W N H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$4
,= AN OPPOSITE IS SIMULTANE\S 0NATURE )
XS OPPOSITE1 & :AT IS SIMULTANE\S
0NATURE OR IS PO/]IOR 6X DOES N MAKE XS
SUBJECT M 9TELLIGI#4 ,?US 7E4G47 ANY "O
:O HAS SD T X IS A PROP]TY ( GD 6BE ,8!
MO/ DIRECT OPPOSITE ( EVIL0'1 HAS
EMPLOY$ ! OPPOSITE ( GD1 & S ! PROP]TY (
GD CD N H BE5 CORRECTLY R5D]$4 ,=
3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE
:E!R HE HAS AVOID$ EMPLOY+ ANY?+ EI
OPPOSITE TO1 OR1 9 G5]AL1 SIMULTANE\S
0NATURE )! SUBJECT1 OR PO/]IOR 6X3 = !N
! PROP]TY W 9 ? RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY
R5D]$4 ,?US 7E4G47 A MAN :O HAS /AT$ T X
IS A PROP]TY ( K 6BE ,8! MO/ 3V9C+
3CEP;N0' HAS AVOID$ EMPLOY+ ANY?+ EI
OPPOSITE TO1 OR SIMULTANE\S 0NATURE )1
OR PO/]IOR TO1 ! SUBJECT2 & S ! PROP]TY
( K WD 9 ? RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE :E!R
HE HAS R5D]$ Z PROP]TY "S?+ T DOES N ALW
FOLL[ ! SUBJECT B "S"TS C1SES 6BE XS
PROP]TY3 = !N ! PROP]TY W N H BE5
CORRECTLY DESCRIB$4 ,= "! IS NO NECESS;Y
EI T ! "N (! SUBJECT M/ AL 2 TRUE (
ANY?+ 6: WE F9D S* AN ATTRIBUTE 2L;G+2
NOR YET T ! "N (! SUBJECT W 2 UNTRUE (
ANY?+ 6: S* AN ATTRIBUTE IS F.D N 62L;G4
,MOREOV]1 9 A4I;N 6?1 EV5 AF HE HAS
R5D]$ ! PROP]TY X W N 2 CLE> :E!R X
2L;GS1 SEE+ T X IS ! K9D ( ATTRIBUTE T
MAY FALL3 & S ! PROP]TY W N 2 CLE>4 ,?US
7E4G47 A MAN :O HAS /AT$ T X IS A
PROP]TY ( ANIMAL ,8"S"TS 6MOVE & "S"TS
6/& /0' R5D]$ ! K9D ( PROP]TY : "S"TS IS
N A PROP]TY1 & S ! PROP]TY CD N H BE5
CORRECTLY /AT$4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
ON ! O!R H&1 SEE :E!R HE HAS R5D]$ "S?+
T ( NECESS;Y M/ ALW 2 A PROP]TY3 = !N !
PROP]TY W H BE5 9 ? RESPECT CORRECTLY
/AT$4 ,?US 7E4G47 A MAN :O HAS /AT$ T X
IS A PROP]TY ( VIRTUE 6BE ,8:AT MAKES XS
POSSESSOR GD0' HAS R5D]$ Z PROP]TY "S?+
T ALW FOLL[S1 & S ! PROP]TY ( VIRTUE WD
9 ? RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY R5D]$4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE :E!R
9 R5D]+ ! PROP]TY (! PRES5T "T HE HAS
OMITT$ 6MAKE A DEF9ITE PROVISO T X IS !
PROP]TY (! PRES5T "T : HE IS R5D]+3 =
ELSE ! PROP]TY W N H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$4
,= 9 ! F/ PLACE1 ANY UNUSUAL PROC$URE
ALW NE$S A DEF9ITE PROVISO3 & X IS !
USUAL PROC$URE = "EYBODY 6R5D] Z PROP]TY
"S ATTRIBUTE T ALW FOLL[S4 ,9 ! SECOND
PLACE1 A MAN :O OMITS 6PROVIDE DEF9ITELY
:E!R X 0 ! PROP]TY (! PRES5T "T : HE
9T5D$ 6/ATE1 IS OBSCURE3 & "O %D N GIVE
ANY O3A.N = ADV]SE CRITICISM4 ,?US
7E4G47 A MAN :O HAS /AT$ X Z ! PROP]TY (
A "PICUL> MAN ,86BE SITT+ )A "PICUL>
MAN0'1 /ATES ! PROP]TY (! PRES5T "T1 & S
HE _C H R5D]$ ! PROP]TY CORRECTLY1 SEE+
T HE HAS DESCRIB$ X )\T ANY DEF9ITE
PROVISO4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R
H&1 SEE :E!R1 9 R5D]+ ! PROP]TY (!
PRES5T "T1 HE HAS1 9 /AT+ X1 MADE A
DEF9ITE PROVISO T X IS ! PROP]TY (!
PRES5T "T T HE IS /AT+3 = !N ! PROP]TY W
9 ? RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$4 ,?US
7E4G47 A MAN :O HAS SD T X IS ! PROP]TY
(A "PICUL> MAN ,86BE WALK+ N[0'1 HAS
MADE ? 4T9C;N 9 8 /ATE;T1 & S ! PROP]TY
WD H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE :E!R
HE HAS R5D]$ A PROP]TY (! K9D ^:
APPROPRIATE;S IS N OBVI\S EXCEPT 0S5S,N3
= !N ! PROP]TY W N H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$4
,= E S5SI# ATTRIBUTE1 ONCE X IS TAK5 2Y
! SPH]E ( S5S,N1 2COMES UNC]TA94 ,= X IS
N CLE> :E!R X / 2L;GS1 2C X IS EVID;ED
ONLY 0S5S,N4 ,? PR9CIPLE W 2 TRUE 9 !
CASE ( ANY ATTRIBUTES T D N ALW &
NECESS>ILY FOLL[4 ,?US 7E4G47 ANY "O :O
HAS /AT$ T X IS A PROP]TY (! SUN 6BE ,8!
B"RE/ /> T MOVES OV] ! E>?0'1 HAS US$ 9
DESCRIB+ ! PROP]TY AN EXPRES.N ( T K9D1
VIZ4 ,86MOVE OV] ! E>?0'1 : IS EVID;ED
0S5S,N2 & S ! SUN'S PROP]TY CD N H BE5
CORRECTLY R5D]$3 = X W 2 UNC]TA91 :5"E !
SUN SETS1 :E!R X 3T9UES 6MOVE OV] ! E>?1
2C S5S,N !N FAILS U4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE :E!R HE HAS
R5D]$ ! PROP]TY (A K9D T IS N OBVI\S
6S5S,N1 OR1 IF X 2 S5SI#1 M/ CLE>LY 2L;G
( NECESS;Y3 = !N ! PROP]TY W 9 ? RESPECT
H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$4 ,?US 7E4G47 A MAN
:O HAS /AT$ T X IS A PROP]TY (A SURFACE
6BE ,8! PRIM>Y ?+ T IS COL\R$0'1 HAS
9TRODUC$ AM;G/ ! RE/ A S5SI# QUAL;Y1
,86BE COL\R$0'1 B / A QUAL;Y S* Z
MANIFE/LY ALW 2L;GS1 & S ! PROP]TY (
,8SURFACE0' WD 9 ? RESPECT H BE5
CORRECTLY R5D]$4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE :E!R
HE HAS R5D]$ ! DEF9I;N Z A PROP]TY3 = !N
! PROP]TY W N H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$3 =!
PROP]TY (A ?+ "\ N 6%[ XS ESS;E4 ,?US
7E4G47 A MAN :O HAS SD T X IS ! PROP]TY
( MAN 6BE 'A WALK+1 BIP$ ANIMAL0' HAS
R5D]$ A PROP]TY ( MAN S Z 6SIGNIFY 8
ESS;E1 & S ! PROP]TY ( MAN CD N H BE5
CORRECTLY R5D]$4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
ON ! O!R H&1 SEE :E!R ! PROP]TY : HE HAS
R5D]$ =MS A PR$ICATE 3V]TI# ) XS
SUBJECT1 )\T1 H["E1 SIGNIFY+ XS ESS;E3 =
!N ! PROP]TY W 9 ? RESPECT H BE5
CORRECTLY R5D]$4 ,?US 7E4G47 HE :O HAS
/AT$ T X IS A PROP]TY ( MAN 6BE A
,8NATUR,Y CIVILIZ$ ANIMAL0' HAS R5D]$ !
PROP]TY S Z 6BE 3V]TI# ) XS SUBJECT1
)\T1 H["E1 %[+ XS ESS;E1 & S ! PROP]TY (
MAN0' WD 9 ? RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY
R5D]$4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE :E!R
HE HAS R5D]$ ! PROP]TY )\T HAV+ PLAC$ !
SUBJECT )9 XS ESS;E4 ,=( PROP]TIES1 Z AL
( DEF9I;NS1 ! F/ T]M 6BE R5D]$ %D 2 !
G5US1 & !N ! RE/ ( X %D 2 APP5D$ IMMLY
AFWS1 & %D 4T+UI% XS SUBJECT F O!R ?+S4
,H;E A PROP]TY : IS N /AT$ 9 ? WAY CD N
H BE5 CORRECTLY R5D]$4 ,?US 7E4G47 A MAN
:O HAS SD T X IS A PROP]TY (A LIV+
CR1TURE TO ,8H A S\L0' HAS N PLAC$
,8LIV+ CR1TURE0' )9 XS ESS;E1 & S !
PROP]TY (A LIV+ CR1TURE CD N H BE5
CORRECTLY /AT$4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
ON ! O!R H&1 SEE :E!R A MAN F/ PLACES )9
XS ESS;E ! SUBJECT ^: PROP]TY HE IS
R5D]+1 & !N APP5DS ! RE/3 = !N ! PROP]TY
W 9 ? RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY R5D]$4
,?US 7E4G47 HE :O HAS /AT$ T IS A
PROP]TY ( MAN 6BE AN ,8ANIMAL CAPA# (
RCVG K0'1 HAS R5D]$ ! PROP]TY AF PLAC+ !
SUBJECT )9 XS ESS;E1 & S ! PROP]TY (
,8MAN0' WD 9 ? RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY
R5D]$4
                   #D
  ,! 9QUIRY1 !N1 :E!R ! PROP]TY HAS BE5
CORRECTLY R5D]$ OR NO1 %D 2 MADE 0^!
M1NS4 ,! "Q1 ON ! O!R H&1 :E!R :AT IS
/AT$ IS OR IS N A PROP]TY AT ALL1 Y %D
EXAM9E F ! FOLL[+ PO9TS ( VIEW4 ,=!
-MONPLACE >GU;TS : E/ABLI% ABSOLUTELY T
! PROP]TY IS A3URATELY /AT$ W 2 ! SAME Z
^? T 3/ITUTE X A PROP]TY AT ALL3 ACLY !Y
W 2 DESCRIB$ 9 ! C\RSE ( !M4
  ,F/LY1 !N1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 TAKE
A LOOK AT EA* SUBJECT ( : HE HAS R5D]$ !
PROP]TY1 & SEE 7E4G47 IF X FAILS 62L;G
6ANY ( !M AT ALL1 OR 6BE TRUE ( !M 9 T
"PICUL> RESPECT1 OR 6BE A PROP]TY ( EA*
( !M 9 RESPECT ( T "* ( : HE HAS R5D]$ !
PROP]TY3 = !N :AT IS /AT$ 6BE A PROP]TY
W N 2 A PROP]TY4 ,?US1 = EXAMPLE1 9ASM*
Z X IS N TRUE (! GEOMETRICIAN T HE ,8_C
2 DCVD 0AN >GU;T0' 7=A GEOMETRICIAN IS
DCVD :5 8 FIGURE IS MISDRAWN71 X CD N 2
A PROP]TY (! MAN ( SCI;E T HE IS N DCVD
0AN >GU;T4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON !
O!R H&1 SEE :E!R ! PROP]TY R5D]$ 2 TRUE
( E 9/.E1 & TRUE 9 T "PICUL> RESPECT3 =
!N :AT IS /AT$ N 6BE A PROP]TY W 2 A
PROP]TY4 ,?US1 = EXAMPLE1 9 Z M* Z !
DESCRIP;N ,8AN ANIMAL CAPA# ( RCVG K0'
IS TRUE ( E MAN1 & TRUE ( HM QUA MAN1 X
WD 2 A PROP]TY ( MAN 6BE ,8AN ANIMAL
CAPA# ( RCVG K0'4 -MONPLACE RULE M1NS-=
DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF ! DESCRIP;N
FAILS 6BE TRUE ( T ( : ! "N IS TRUE2 &
IF ! "N FAILS 6BE TRUE ( T ( : !
DESCRIP;N IS TRUE3 = 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF ! DESCRIP;N TOO IS
PR$ICAT$ ( T ( : ! "N IS PR$ICAT$1 & IF
! "N TOO IS PR$ICAT$ ( T ( : ! DESCRIP;N
IS PR$ICAT$47'
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF !
DESCRIP;N FAILS 6APPLY 6T 6: ! "N
APPLIES1 & IF ! "N FAILS 6APPLY 6T 6: !
DESCRIP;N APPLIES3 = !N :AT IS /AT$ 6BE
A PROP]TY W N 2 A PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47
9ASM* Z ! DESCRIP;N 'A LIV+ 2+ T P>TAKES
( K0' IS TRUE ( ,GOD1 :ILE ,8MAN0' IS N
PR$ICAT$ ( ,GOD1 6BE A LIV+ 2+ T P>TAKES
( K0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY ( MAN4 ,=
3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF
! "N Z WELL 2 PR$ICAT$ ( T ( : !
DESCRIP;N IS PR$ICAT$1 & IF ! DESCRIP;N
Z WELL 2 PR$ICAT$ ( T ( : ! "N IS
PR$ICAT$4 ,= !N :AT IS /AT$ N 6BE A
PROP]TY W 2 A PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47 !
PR$ICATE ,8LIV+ CR1TURE0' IS TRUE ( T (
: ,8HAV+ A S\L0' IS TRUE1 & ,8HAV+ A
S\L0' IS TRUE ( T ( : ! PR$ICATE ,8LIV+
CR1TURE0' IS TRUE2 & S ,8HAV+ A S\L WD 2
A PROP]TY ( ,8LIV+ CR1TURE0'4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF
HE HAS R5D]$ A SUBJECT Z A PROP]TY ( T :
IS DESCRIB$ Z ,8IN ! SUBJECT0'3 = !N :AT
HAS BE5 /AT$ 6BE A PROP]TY W N 2 A
PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z HE :O HAS
R5D]$ ,8FIRE0' Z ! PROP]TY ( ,8! BODY )!
MO/ R>EFI$ "PICLES0'1 HAS R5D]$ !
SUBJECT Z ! PROP]TY ( XS PR$ICATE1
,8FIRE0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY ( ,8! BODY )!
MO/ R>EFI$ "PICLES0'4 ,! R1SON :Y !
SUBJECT W N 2 A PROP]TY ( T : IS F.D 9 !
SUBJECT IS ?1 T !N ! SAME ?+ W 2 !
PROP]TY (A NUMB] ( ?+S T >E SPECIFIC,Y
DI6]5T4 ,=! SAME ?+ HAS Q A NUMB] (
SPECIFIC,Y DI6]5T PR$ICATES T 2L;G 6X
AL"O1 &! SUBJECT W 2 A PROP]TY ( ALL (
^!1 IF ANY "O /ATES ! PROP]TY 9 ? WAY4
,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE
IF HE HAS R5D]$ :AT IS F.D 9 ! SUBJECT Z
A PROP]TY (! SUBJECT3 = !N :AT HAS BE5
/AT$ N 6BE A PROP]TY W 2 A PROP]TY1 IF X
2 PR$ICAT$ ONLY (! ?+S ( : X HAS BE5
/AT$ 6BE ! PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47 HE :O
HAS SD T X IS A PROP]TY ( ,8E>?0' 6BE
,8SPECIFIC,Y ! H1VIE/ BODY0' HAS R5D]$ (
! SUBJECT Z XS PROP]TY "S?+ T IS SD (!
?+ 9 "Q AL"O1 & IS SD ( X 9 ! MANN] 9 :
A PROP]TY IS PR$ICAT$1 & S ! PROP]TY (
E>? WD H BE5 "RLY /AT$4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF
HE HAS R5D]$ ! PROP]TY Z P>TAK5 (3 = !N
:AT IS /AT$ 6BE A PROP]TY W N 2 A
PROP]TY4 ,= AN ATTRIBUTE ( : ! SUBJECT
P>TAKES IS A 3/ITU5T "P ( XS ESS;E3 & AN
ATTRIBUTE ( T K9D WD 2 A DI6]5TIA APPLY+
6"S "O SPECIES4 ,E4G4 9ASM* Z HE :O HAS
SD T ,8WALK+ ON TWO FEET0' IS PROP]TY (
MAN HAS R5D]$ ! PROP]TY Z P>TAK5 (1
,8WALK+ ON TWO FEET0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY (
,8MAN0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R
H&1 SEE IF HE HAS AVOID$ R5D]+ ! PROP]TY
Z P>TAK5 (1 OR Z %[+ ! ESS;E1 ?\< !
SUBJECT IS PR$ICAT$ 3V]TIBLY ) X3 = !N
:AT IS /AT$ N 6BE A PROP]TY W 2 A
PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47 HE :O HAS /AT$ T
6BE ,8NATUR,Y S5TI5T0' IS A PROP]TY (
,8ANIMAL0' HAS R5D]$ ! PROP]TY NEI Z
P>TAK5 ( NOR Z %[+ ! ESS;E1 ?\< !
SUBJECT IS PR$ICAT$ 3V]TIBLY ) X2 & S
6BE ,8NATUR,Y S5TI5T0' WD 2 A PROP]TY (
,8ANIMAL0'4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF !
PROP]TY _C POSSIBLY 2L;G SIMULTANE\SLY1
B M/ 2L;G EI Z PO/]IOR OR Z PRIOR 6!
ATTRIBUTE DESCRIB$ 9 ! "N3 = !N :AT IS
/AT$ 6BE A PROP]TY W N 2 A PROP]TY EI
N"E1 OR N ALW4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z X IS
POSSI# =! ATTRIBUTE ,8WALK+ "? ! M>KET-
PLACE0' 62L;G 6AN OBJECT Z PRIOR & Z
PO/]IOR 6! ATTRIBUTE ,8MAN0'1 ,8WALK+ "?
! M>KET-PLACE0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY (
,8MAN0' EI N"E1 OR N ALW4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF X ALW &(
NECESS;Y 2L;GS SIMULTANE\SLY1 )\T 2+ EI
A DEF9I;N OR A DI6]5TIA3 = !N :AT IS
/AT$ N 6BE A PROP]TY W 2 A PROP]TY4 ,?US
7E4G47 ! ATTRIBUTE ,8AN ANIMAL CAPA# (
RCVG K0' ALW &( NECESS;Y 2L;GS
SIMULTANE\SLY )! ATTRIBUTE ,8MAN0'1 & IS
NEI DI6]5TIA NOR DEF9I;N ( XS SUBJECT1 &
S ,8AN ANIMAL CAPA# ( RCVG K0' WD 2 A
PROP]TY ( ,8MAN0'4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF !
SAME ?+ FAILS 6BE A PROP]TY ( ?+S T >E !
SAME Z ! SUBJECT1 S F> Z !Y >E ! SAME3 =
!N :AT IS /AT$ 6BE A PROP]TY W N 2 A
PROP]TY4 ,?US1 = EXAMPLE1 9ASM* Z X IS
NO PROP]TY (A ,8PROP] OBJECT ( PURSUIT0'
TO ,8APPE> GD 6C]TA9 P]SONS0'1 X CD N 2
A PROP]TY (! ,8DESIRA#0' EI TO ,8APPE>
GD 6C]TA9 P]SONS0'3 = ,8PROP] OBJECT (
PURSUIT0' & ,8DESIRA#0' M1N ! SAME4 ,=
3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF
! SAME ?+ 2 A PROP]TY ( "S?+ T IS ! SAME
Z ! SUBJECT1 9 S F> Z X IS ! SAME4 ,= !N
IS /AT$ N 6BE A PROP]TY W 2 A PROP]TY4
,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z X IS CALL$ A PROP]TY
(A MAN1 9 S F> Z HE IS A MAN1 ,86H A
TRI"PITE S\L0'1 X WD AL 2 A PROP]TY (A
MORTAL1 9 S F> Z HE IS A MORTAL1 6H A
TRI"PITE S\L4 ,? -MONPLACE RULE IS USE;L
AL 9 D1L+ ) ,A3ID5T3 =! SAME ATTRIBUTES
"\ EI 62L;G OR N 2L;G 6! SAME ?+S1 9 S
F> Z !Y >E ! SAME4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF !
PROP]TY ( ?+S T >E ! SAME 9 K9D Z !
SUBJECT FAILS 6BE ALW ! SAME 9 K9D Z !
ALLEG$ PROP]TY3 = !N NEI W :AT IS /AT$
6BE ! PROP]TY (! SUBJECT 9 "Q4 ,?US
7E4G47 9ASM* Z A MAN &A HORSE >E ! SAME
9 K9D1 & X IS N ALW A PROP]TY (A HORSE
6/& 0XS [N 9ITIATIVE1 X CD N 2 A PROP]TY
(A MAN 6MOVE 0HIS [N 9ITIATIVE2 = 6/& &
6MOVE 0HIS [N 9ITIATIVE >E ! SAME 9 K9D1
2C !Y 2L;G 6EA* ( !M 9 S F> Z EA* IS AN
,8ANIMAL0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON !
O!R H&1 SEE IF ( ?+S T >E ! SAME 9 K9D Z
! SUBJECT ! PROP]TY T IS ! SAME Z !
ALLEG$ PROP]TY IS ALW TRUE3 = !N :AT IS
/AT$ N 6BE A PROP]TY W 2 A PROP]TY4 ,?US
7E4G47 S9CE X IS A PROP]TY ( MAN 6BE A
,8WALK+ BIP$10' X WD AL 2 A PROP]TY (A
BIRD 6BE A ,8FLY+ BIP$0'3 = EA* ( ^! IS
! SAME 9 K9D1 9 S F> Z ! "O PAIR H !
SAME;S ( SPECIES T FALL "U ! SAME G5US1
2+ "U ! G5US ,8ANIMAL0'1 :ILE ! O!R PAIR
H T ( DI6]5TIAE (! G5US1 VIZ4 (
,8ANIMAL0'4 ,? -MONPLACE RULE IS
DECEPTIVE :5"E "O (! PROP]TIES M5;N$
2L;GS 6"S "O SPECIES ONLY :ILE ! O!R
2L;GS 6_M1 Z DOES ,8WALK+ QUADRUP$0'4
  ,9ASM* Z ,8SAME0' & ,8DI6]5T0' >E T]MS
US$ 9 S"EAL S5SES1 X IS A JOB 6R5D] 6A
SOPHI/ICAL "Q] A PROP]TY T 2L;GS 6"O ?+
& T ONLY4 ,= AN ATTRIBUTE T 2L;GS 6"S?+
QUALIFI$ 0AN A3ID5T W AL 2L;G 6! A3ID5T
TAK5 AL;G )! SUBJECT : X QUALIFIES2 E4G4
AN ATTRIBUTE T 2L;GS TO ,8MAN0' W 2L;G
AL TO ,8:ITE MAN0'1 IF "! 2 A :ITE MAN1
& "O T 2L;GS TO ,8:ITE MAN0' W 2L;G AL
TO ,8MAN0'4 ,"O MI<T1 !N1 BR+ CAPTI\S
CRITICISM AG/ ! MAJOR;Y ( PROP]TIES1
0REPRES5T+ ! SUBJECT Z 2+ "O ?+ 9 XF1 &
ANO!R ?+ :5 -B9$ ) XS A3ID5T1 SAY+1 =
EXAMPLE1 T ,8MAN0' IS "O ?+1 & :ITE
MAN0' ANO!R1 & MOREOV] 0REPRES5T+ Z
DI6]5T A C]TA9 /ATE & :AT IS CALL$ AF T
/ATE4 ,= AN ATTRIBUTE T 2L;GS 6! /ATE W
2L;G AL 6:AT IS CALL$ AF T /ATE1 & "O T
2L;GS 6:AT IS CALL$ AF A /ATE W 2L;G AL
6! /ATE3 E4G4 9ASM* Z ! 3DI;N (! SCI5TI/
IS CALL$ AF 8 SCI;E1 X CD N 2 A PROP]TY
( ,8SCI;E0' T X IS ,89CONTROV]TI#
0>GU;T0'2 = !N ! SCI5TI/ AL W 2
9CONTROV]TI# 0>GU;T4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 H["E1 Y %D SAY T ! SUBJECT (
AN A3ID5T IS N ABSOLUTELY DI6]5T F !
A3ID5T TAK5 AL;G ) XS SUBJECT2 ?\< X IS
CALL$ ,8ANO!R0' ?+ 2C ! MODE ( 2+ (! TWO
IS DI6]5T3 = X IS N ! SAME ?+ =A MAN 6BE
A MAN &=A :ITE MAN 6BE A :ITE MAN4
,MOREOV]1 Y %D TAKE A LOOK AL;G AT !
9FLEC;NS1 & SAY T ! DESCRIP;N (! MAN (
SCI;E IS WR;G3 "O %D SAY N ,8X0' B ,8HE
IS 9CONTROV]TI# 0>GU;T0'2 :ILE !
DESCRIP;N ( ,SCI;E IS WR;G TOO3 "O %D
SAY N ,8X0' B ,8%E IS 9CONTROV]TI#
0>GU;T0'4 ,= AG/ AN OBJECTOR :O /ICKS AT
NO?+ ! DEF;E %D /ICK AT NO?+4
                   #E
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF1
:ILE 9T5D+ 6R5D] AN ATTRIBUTE T NATUR,Y
2L;GS1 HE /ATES X 9 8 LANGUAGE 9 S* A
WAY Z 69DICATE "O T 9V>IABLY 2L;GS3 = !N
X WD 2 G5],Y AGRE$ T :AT HAS BE5 /AT$
6BE A PROP]TY IS UPSET4 ,?US 7E4G47 !
MAN :O HAS SD T ,8BIP$0' IS A PROP]TY (
MAN 9T5DS 6R5D] ! ATTRIBUTE T NATUR,Y
2L;GS1 B 8 EXPRES.N ACTU,Y 9DICATES "O T
9V>IABLY 2L;GS3 ACLY1 ,8BIP$0' CD N 2 A
PROP]TY ( MAN3 = N E MAN IS POSSESS$ (
TWO FEET4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON !
O!R H&1 SEE IF HE 9T5DS 6R5D] ! PROP]TY
T NATUR,Y 2L;GS1 & 9DICATES X 9 T WAY 9
8 LANGUAGE3 = !N ! PROP]TY W N 2 UPSET 9
? RESPECT4 ,?US 7E4G47 HE :O R5D]S Z A
PROP]TY ( ,8MAN0' ! PHRASE ,8AN ANIMAL
CAPA# ( RCVG K0' BO? 9T5DS1 & 0HIS
LANGUAGE 9DICATES1 ! PROP]TY T 2L;GS
0NATURE1 & S ,8AN ANIMAL CAPA# ( RCVG
K0' WD N 2 UPSET OR %[N 9 T RESPECT N
6BE A PROP]TY ( MAN4
  ,MOREOV]1 Z REG>DS ALL ! ?+S T >E
CALL$ Z !Y >E PRIM>ILY AF "S?+ ELSE1 OR
PRIM>ILY 9 !MVS1 X IS A JOB 6R5D] !
PROP]TY ( S* ?+S4 ,= IF Y R5D] A PROP]TY
Z 2L;G+ 6! SUBJECT T IS S CALL$ AF "S?+
ELSE1 !N X W 2 TRUE ( XS PRIM>Y SUBJECT
Z WELL2 ":AS IF Y /ATE X ( XS PRIM>Y
SUBJECT1 !N X W 2 PR$ICAT$ AL (! ?+ T IS
S CALL$ AF ? O!R4 ,?US 7E4G47 IF ANY "O
R5D]S @1 COL\R$0' Z ! PROP]TY (
,8SURFACE0'1 ,8COL\R$0' W 2 TRUE ( BODY
Z WELL2 ":AS IF HE R5D] X ( ,8BODY0'1 X
W 2 PR$ICAT$ AL ( ,8SURFACE0'4 ,H;E ! "N
Z WELL W N 2 TRUE ( T ( : ! DESCRIP;N IS
TRUE4
  ,9 ! CASE ( "S PROP]TIES X MO/LY
HAPP5S T "S ]ROR IS 9CURR$ 2C (A FAILURE
6DEF9E H[ Z WELL Z 6:AT ?+S ! PROP]TY IS
/AT$ 62L;G4 ,= E "O TRIES 6R5D] Z !
PROP]TY (A ?+ "S?+ T 2L;GS 6X EI
NATUR,Y1 Z ,8BIP$0' 2L;GS TO ,8MAN0'1 OR
ACTU,Y1 Z ,8HAV+ F\R F+]S0' 2L;GS 6A
"PICUL> MAN1 OR SPECIFIC,Y1 Z ,83SI/+ (
MO/ R>EFI$ "PICLES0' 2L;GS TO ,8FIRE0'1
OR ABSOLUTELY1 Z ,8LIFE0' TO ,8LIV+
2+0'1 OR "O T 2L;GS 6A ?+ ONLY Z CALL$
AF "S?+ ELSE1 Z ,8WISDOM0' 6! ,8S\L0'1
OR ON ! O!R H& PRIM>ILY1 Z ,8WISDOM0' 6!
,8R,NAL FACULTY0'1 OR 2C ! ?+ IS 9 A
C]TA9 /ATE1 Z ,89CONTROV]TI# 0>GU;T0'
2L;GS 6A ,8SCI5TI/0' 7= SIMPLY & SOLELY
0R1SON ( 8 2+ 9 A C]TA9 /ATE W HE 2
,89CONTROV]TI# 0>GU;T0'71 OR 2C X IS !
/ATE POSSESS$ 0"S?+1 Z ,89CONTROV]TI#
0>GU;T0' 2L;GS TO ,8SCI;E0'1 OR 2C X IS
P>TAK5 (1 Z ,8S5S,N0' 2L;GS TO
,8ANIMAL0' 7= O!R ?+S Z WELL H S5S,N1
E4G4 MAN1 B !Y H X 2C !Y ALR P>TAKE (
,8ANIMAL0'71 OR 2C X P>TAKES ( "S?+
ELSE1 Z ,8LIFE0' 2L;GS 6A "PICUL> K9D (
,8LIV+ 2+0'4 ,ACLY HE MAKES A MISTAKE IF
HE HAS FAIL$ 6ADD ! ^W ,8NATUR,Y0'1 2C
:AT 2L;GS NATUR,Y MAY FAIL 62L;G 6! ?+
6: X NATUR,Y 2L;GS1 Z 7E4G47 X 2L;GS 6A
MAN 6H TWO FEET3 S TOO HE ]RS IF HE DOES
N MAKE A DEF9ITE PROVISO T HE IS R5D]+
:AT ACTU,Y 2L;GS1 2C "O "D T ATTRIBUTE W
N 2 :AT X N[ IS1 E4G4 ! MAN'S POSSES.N (
F\R F+]S4 ,S HE ]RS IF HE HAS N %[N T HE
/ATES A ?+ 6BE S* & S* PRIM>ILY1 OR T HE
CALLS X S AF "S?+ ELSE1 2C !N XS "N TOO
W N 2 TRUE ( T ( : ! DESCRIP;N IS TRUE1
Z IS ! CASE ) ,8COL\R$0'1 :E!R R5D]$ Z A
PROP]TY ( ,8SURFACE0' OR ( ,8BODY0'4 ,S
HE ]RS IF HE HAS N SD 2FH& T HE HAS
R5D]$ A PROP]TY 6A ?+ EI 2C T ?+
POSSESSES A /ATE1 OR 2C X IS A /ATE
POSSESS$ 0"S?+2 2C !N X W N 2 A PROP]TY4
,=1 SUPPOS+ HE R5D]S ! PROP]TY 6"S?+ Z
2+ A /ATE POSSESS$1 X W 2L;G 6:AT
POSSESSES T /ATE2 :ILE SUPPOS+ HE R5D]S
X 6:AT POSSESSES ! /ATE1 X W 2L;G 6!
/ATE POSSESS$1 Z DID ,89CONTROV]TI#
0>GU;T0' :5 /AT$ Z A PROP]TY ( ,8SCI;E0'
OR (! ,8SCI5TI/0'4 ,S HE ]RS IF HE HAS N
9DICAT$ 2FH& T ! PROP]TY 2L;GS 2C ! ?+
P>TAKES (1 OR IS P>TAK5 ( BY1 "S?+2 2C
!N ! PROP]TY W 2L;G 6C]TA9 O!R ?+S Z
WELL4 ,= IF HE R5D]S X 2C XS SUBJECT IS
P>TAK5 (1 X W 2L;G 6! ?+S : P>TAKE ( X2
":AS IF HE R5D]S X 2C XS SUBJECT P>TAKES
( "S?+ ELSE1 X W 2L;G 6! ?+S P>TAK5 (1 Z
7E4G47 IF HE 7 6/ATE ,8LIFE0' 6BE A
PROP]TY (A ,8"PICUL> K9D ( LIV+ 2+0'1 OR
J ( ,8LIV+ 2+4 ,S HE ]RS IF HE HAS N
EXPRESSLY 4T+UI%$ ! PROP]TY T 2L;GS
SPECIFIC,Y1 2C !N X W 2L;G ONLY 6"O (!
?+S T FALL "U ! T]M ( : HE /ATES !
PROP]TY3 =! SUP]LATIVE 2L;GS ONLY 6"O (
!M1 E4G4 ,8LI<TE/0' Z APPLI$ TO
,8FIRE0'4 ,"S"TS1 TOO1 A MAN MAY EV5 ADD
! ^W ,8SPECIFIC,Y0'1 & / MAKE A MISTAKE4
,=! ?+S 9 "Q %D ALL 2 ( "O SPECIES1 :5"E
! ^W ,8SPECIFIC,Y0' IS A4$3 & 9 "S CASES
? DOES N O3UR1 Z X DOES N1 9 FACT1 9 !
CASE ( FIRE4 ,= FIRE IS N ALL ( "O
SPECIES2 = LIVE COALS & FLAME & LI<T >E
EA* ( !M ,8FIRE0'1 B >E ( DI6]5T
SPECIES4 ,! R1SON :Y1 :5"E
,8SPECIFIC,Y0' IS A4$1 "! %D N 2 ANY
SPECIES O!R ?AN ! "O M5;N$1 IS ?1 T IF
"! BE1 !N ! PROP]TY 9 "Q W 2L;G 6"S ( !M
9 A GRT] & 6O!RS 9 A LESS DEGREE1 Z
HAPP5S ) ,83SI/+ ( MO/ R>EFI$ "PICLES0'
9 ! CASE ( FIRE3 = ,8LI<T0' 3SI/S ( M
R>EFI$ "PICLES ?AN LIVE COALS & FLAME4
,& ? %D N HAPP5 UN.S ! "N TOO 2 PR$ICAT$
9 A GRT] DEGREE ( T ( : ! DESCRIP;N IS
TRU]2 O!RWISE ! RULE T ": ! DESCRIP;N IS
TRU] ! "N TOO %D 2 TRU] IS N FULFILL$4
,MOREOV]1 9 A4I;N 6?1 ! SAME ATTRIBUTE W
2 ! PROP]TY BO? (! T]M : HAS X
ABSOLUTELY &( T ELE;T "!9 : HAS X 9 !
HI<E/ DEGREE1 Z IS ! 3DI;N (! PROP]TY
,83SI/+ ( MO/ R>EFI$ "PICLES0' 9 ! CASE
( ,8FIRE0'3 = ? SAME ATTRIBUTE W 2 !
PROP]TY ( ,8LI<T0' Z WELL3 = X IS
,8LI<T0' T ,83SI/S (! MO/ R>EFI$
"PICLES0'4 ,IF1 !N1 ANY "O ELSE R5D]S A
PROP]TY 9 ? WAY "O %D ATTACK X2 = "OF1
"O %D N GIVE O3A.N = ? OBJEC;N1 B %D
DEF9E 9 :AT MANN] "O /ATES ! PROP]TY AT
! ACTUAL "T ( MAK+ ! /ATE;T4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF
HE HAS /AT$ A ?+ Z A PROP]TY ( XF3 = !N
:AT HAS BE5 /AT$ 6BE A PROP]TY W N 2 A
PROP]TY4 ,=A ?+ XF ALW %[S XS [N ESS;E1
& :AT %[S ! ESS;E IS N A PROP]TY B A
DEF9I;N4 ,?US 7E4G47 HE :O HAS SD T
,82COM+0' IS A PROP]TY ( ,8B1UTI;L0' HAS
R5D]$ ! T]M Z A PROP]TY ( XF 7=
,8B1UTI;L0' & ,82COM+0' >E ! SAME72 & S
,82COM+0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY (
,8B1UTI;L0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON !
O!R H&1 SEE IF HE HAS AVOID$ R5D]+ A ?+
Z A PROP]TY ( XF1 B HAS YET /AT$ A
3V]TI# PR$ICATE3 = !N :AT IS /AT$ N 6BE
A PROP]TY W 2 A PROP]TY4 ,?US HE :O HAS
/AT$ ,8ANIMATE SUB/.E0' Z A PROP]TY (
,8LIV+-CR1TURE0' HAS N /AT$ ,8LIV+-
CR1TURE0' Z A PROP]TY ( XF1 B HAS R5D]$
A 3V]TI# PR$ICATE1 S T ,8ANIMATE
SUB/.E0' WD 2 A PROP]TY ( ,8LIV+-
CR1TURE0'4
  ,NEXT1 9 ! CASE ( ?+S 3SI/+ ( L "PS1 Y
%D LOOK & SEE1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 IF
! PROP]TY (! :OLE 2 N TRUE (! "P1 OR IF
T (! "P 2 N PR$ICAT$ (! :OLE3 = !N :AT
HAS BE5 /AT$ 6BE ! PROP]TY W N 2 A
PROP]TY4 ,9 "S CASES X HAPP5S T ? IS S3
= "S"TS 9 R5D]+ A PROP]TY 9 ! CASE ( ?+S
T 3SI/ ( L "PS A MAN MAY H 8 EYE ON !
:OLE1 :ILE "S"TS HE MAY A4RESS HMF 6:AT
IS PR$ICAT$ (! "P3 & !N 9 NEI CASE W X H
BE5 "RLY R5D]$4 ,TAKE AN 9/.E REF]R+ 6!
:OLE3 ! MAN :O HAS SD T X IS A PROP]TY (
! ,8SEA0' 6BE ,8! L>GE/ VOLUME ( SALT
WAT]0'1 HAS /AT$ ! PROP]TY ( "S?+ T
3SI/S ( L "PS1 B HAS R5D]$ AN ATTRIBUTE
( S* A K9D Z IS N TRUE (! "P 7=A "PICUL>
SEA IS N ,8! L>GE/ VOLUME ( SALT
WAT]0'72 & S ! L>GE/ VOLUME ( SALT
WAT]0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY (! ,8SEA0'4 ,N[
TAKE "O REF]R+ 6! "P3 ! MAN :O HAS /AT$
T X IS A PROP]TY ( ,8AIR0' 6BE
,8BR1?A#0' HAS /AT$ ! PROP]TY ( "S?+ T
3SI/S ( L "PS1 B HE HAS /AT$ AN
ATTRIBUTE S* Z1 ?\< TRUE ( "S AIR1 IS /
N PR$ICA# (! :OLE 7=! :OLE (! AIR IS N
BR1?A#72 & S ,8BR1?A#0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY
( ,8AIR0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON !
O!R H&1 SEE :E!R1 :ILE X IS TRUE ( EA* (
! ?+S ) SIMIL> "PS1 X IS ON ! O!R H& A
PROP]TY ( !M TAK5 Z A COLLECTIVE :OLE3 =
!N :AT HAS BE5 /AT$ N 6BE A PROP]TY W 2
A PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47 :ILE X IS TRUE (
E>? "EY": T X NATUR,Y FALLS D[NW>DS1 X
IS A PROP]TY (! V>I\S "PICUL> PIECES (
E>? TAK5 Z ,8! ,E>?0'1 S T X WD 2 A
PROP]TY ( ,8E>?0' ,8NATUR,Y 6FALL
D[NW>DS0'4
                   #F
  ,NEXT1 LOOK F ! PO9T ( VIEW (!
RESPECTIVE OPPOSITES1 & F/ 7A7 F T (!
3TR>IES1 & SEE1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
IF ! 3TR>Y (! T]M R5D]$ FAILS 6BE A
PROP]TY (! 3TR>Y SUBJECT4 ,= !N NEI W !
3TR>Y (! F/ 2 A PROP]TY (! 3TR>Y (!
SECOND4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z 9JU/ICE IS
3TR>Y 6JU/ICE1 &! L[E/ EVIL 6! HI<E/ GD1
B ,86BE ! HI<E/ GD0' IS N A PROP]TY (
,8JU/ICE0'1 "!=E ,86BE ! L[E/ EVIL0' CD
N 2 A PROP]TY ( ,89JU/ICE0'4 ,=
3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF
! 3TR>Y IS ! PROP]TY (! 3TR>Y3 = !N AL !
3TR>Y (! F/ W 2 ! PROP]TY (! 3TR>Y (!
SECOND4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z EVIL IS
3TR>Y 6GD1 & OBJEC;NA# 6DESIRA#1 &
,8DESIRA#0' IS A PROP]TY ( ,8GD0'1
,8OBJEC;NA#0' WD 2 A PROP]TY ( ,8EVIL0'4
  ,SECONDLY 7H7 LOOK F ! PO9T ( VIEW (
RELATIVE OPPOSITES & SEE1 = DE/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 IF ! CORRELATIVE (! T]M R5D]$
FAILS 6BE A PROP]TY (! CORRELATIVE (!
SUBJECT3 = !N NEI W ! CORRELATIVE (! F/
2 A PROP]TY (! CORRELATIVE (! SECOND4
,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z ,8D\#0' IS RELATIVE
TO ,8HALF0'1 & ,8IN EXCESS0' TO
,8EXCE$$0'1 :ILE ,8IN EXCESS0' IS N A
PROP]TY ( ,8D\#0'1 EXCE$$0' CD N 2 A
PROP]TY ( ,8HALF0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF !
CORRELATIVE (! ALLEG$ PROP]TY IS A
PROP]TY (! SUBJECT'S CORRELATIVE3 = !N
AL ! CORRELATIVE (! F/ W 2 A PROP]TY (!
CORRELATIVE (! SECOND3 E4G4 9ASM* Z
,8D\#0' IS RELATIVE TO ,8HALF0'1 &!
PROPOR;N #A3B IS RELATIVE 6! PROPOR;N
#B3A1 :ILE X IS A PROP]TY ( ,8D\#0' 6BE
,8IN ! PROPOR;N ( #B 6#A0'1 X WD 2 A
PROP]TY ( ,8HALF0' 6BE ,8IN ! PROPOR;N (
#A 6#B0'4
  ,?IRDLY 7C7 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE
IF AN ATTRIBUTE DESCRIB$ 9 T]MS (A /ATE
7,X7 FAILS 6BE A PROP]TY (! GIV5 /ATE
7,Y73 = !N NEI W ! ATTRIBUTE DESCRIB$ 9
T]MS (! PRIV,N 7( ,X7 2 A PROP]TY (!
PRIV,N 7( ,Y74 ,AL IF1 ON ! O!R H&1 AN
ATTRIBUTE DESCRIB$ 9 T]MS (! PRIV,N 7(
,X7 2 N A PROP]TY (! GIV5 PRIV,N 7( ,Y71
NEI W ! ATTRIBUTE DESCRIB$ 9 T]MS (!
/ATE 7,X7 2 A PROP]TY (! /ATE 7,Y74
,?US1 = EXAMPLE1 9ASM* Z X IS N PR$ICAT$
Z A PROP]TY ( ,8D1F;S0' 6BE A ,8LACK (
S5S,N0'1 NEI CD X 2 A PROP]TY ( ,8HE>+0'
6BE A ,8S5S,N0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF AN ATTRIBUTE
DESCRIB$ 9 T]MS (A /ATE 7,X7 IS A
PROP]TY (! GIV5 /ATE 7,Y73 = !N AL !
ATTRIBUTE T IS DESCRIB$ 9 T]MS (! PRIV,N
7( ,X7 W 2 A PROP]TY (! PRIV,N 7( ,Y74
,AL1 IF AN ATTRIBUTE DESCRIB$ 9 T]MS (A
PRIV,N 7( ,X7 2 A PROP]TY (! PRIV,N 7(
,Y71 !N AL ! ATTRIBUTE T IS DESCRIB$ 9
T]MS (! /ATE 7,X7 W 2 A PROP]TY (! /ATE
7,Y74 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z ,86SEE0' IS A
PROP]TY ( ,8SI<T0'1 9ASM* Z WE H SI<T1
,8FAILURE 6SEE0' WD 2 A PROP]TY (
,8BL;S0'1 9ASM* Z WE H N GOT ! SI<T WE
%D NATUR,Y H4
  ,NEXT1 LOOK F ! PO9T ( VIEW ( POSITIVE
& NEGATIVE T]MS2 & F/ 7A7 F ! PO9T (
VIEW (! PR$ICATES TAK5 0!MVS4 ,? -MON-
PLACE RULE IS USE;L ONLY =A DE/RUCTIVE
PURPOSE4 ,?US 7E4G47 SEE IF ! POSITIVE
T]M OR ! ATTRIBUTE DESCRIB$ 9 T]MS ( X
IS A PROP]TY (! SUBJECT3 = !N ! NEGATIVE
T]M OR ! ATTRIBUTE DESCRIB$ 9 T]MS ( X W
N 2 A PROP]TY (! SUBJECT4 ,AL IF1 ON !
O!R H&1 ! NEGATIVE T]M OR ! ATTRIBUTE
DESCRIB$ 9 T]MS ( X IS A PROP]TY (!
SUBJECT1 !N ! POSITIVE T]M OR !
ATTRIBUTE DESCRIB$ 9 T]MS ( X W N 2 A
PROP]TY (! SUBJECT3 E4G4 9ASM* Z
,8ANIMATE0' IS A PROP]TY ( ,8LIV+
CR1TURE0'1 ,89ANIMATE0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY
( ,8LIV+ CR1TURE0'4
  ,SECONDLY 7B7 LOOK F ! PO9T ( VIEW (!
PR$ICATES1 POSITIVE OR NEGATIVE1 & _!
RESPECTIVE SUBJECTS2 & SEE1 = DE/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 IF ! POSITIVE T]M FALLS 6BE A
PROP]TY (! POSITIVE SUBJECT3 = !N NEI W
! NEGATIVE T]M 2 A PROP]TY (! NEGATIVE
SUBJECT4 ,AL1 IF ! NEGATIVE T]M FAILS
6BE A PROP]TY (! NEGATIVE SUBJECT1 NEI W
! POSITIVE T]M 2 A PROP]TY (! POSITIVE
SUBJECT4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z ,8ANIMAL0'
IS N A PROP]TY ( ,8MAN0'1 NEI CD ,8N-
ANIMAL0' 2 A PROP]TY ( ,8N-MAN0'4 ,AL IF
,8N-ANIMAL0' SEEMS N 6BE A PROP]TY (
,8N-MAN0'1 NEI W ,8ANIMAL0' 2 A PROP]TY
( ,8MAN0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON !
O!R H&1 SEE IF ! POSITIVE T]M IS A
PROP]TY (! POSITIVE SUBJECT3 = !N !
NEGATIVE T]M W 2 A PROP]TY (! NEGATIVE
SUBJECT Z WELL4 ,AL IF ! NEGATIVE T]M 2
A PROP]TY (! NEGATIVE SUBJECT1 !
POSITIVE W 2 A PROP]TY (! POSITIVE Z
WELL4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z X IS A PROP]TY
( ,8N-LIV+ 2+0' ,8N 6LIVE0'1 X WD 2 A
PROP]TY ( ,8LIV+ 2+0' ,86LIVE0'3 AL IF X
SEEMS 6BE A PROP]TY ( ,8LIV+ 2+0'
,86LIVE0'1 X W AL SEEM 6BE A PROP]TY (
,8N-LIV+ 2+0' ,8N 6LIVE0'4
  ,?IRDLY 7C7 LOOK F ! PO9T ( VIEW (!
SUBJECTS TAK5 0!MVS1 & SEE1 = DE/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 IF ! PROP]TY R5D]$ IS A
PROP]TY (! POSITIVE SUBJECT3 = !N ! SAME
T]M W N 2 A PROP]TY (! NEGATIVE SUBJECT
Z WELL4 ,AL1 IF ! T]M R5D]$ 2 A PROP]TY
(! NEGATIVE SUBJECT1 X W N 2 A PROP]TY (
! POSITIVE4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z
,8ANIMATE0' IS A PROP]TY ( ,8LIV+
CR1TURE0'1 ,8ANIMATE0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY
( ,8N-LIV+ CR1TURE0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 IF ! T]M R5D]$
FAILS 6BE A PROP]TY (! A6IRMATIVE
SUBJECT X WD 2 A PROP]TY (! NEGATIVE4 ,?
-MONPLACE RULE IS1 H["E1 DECEPTIVE3 =A
POSITIVE T]M IS N A PROP]TY (A NEGATIVE1
OR A NEGATIVE (A POSITIVE4 ,=A POSITIVE
T]M DOES N 2L;G AT ALL 6A NEGATIVE1 :ILE
A NEGATIVE T]M1 ?\< X 2L;GS 6A POSITIVE1
DOES N 2L;G Z A PROP]TY4
  ,NEXT1 LOOK F ! PO9T ( VIEW (!
COORD9ATE MEMB]S (A DIVI.N1 & SEE1 =
DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 IF N"O (! CO-
ORD9ATE MEMB]S 7P>ALLEL )! PROP]TY
R5D]$7 2 A PROP]TY ( ANY (! REMA9+ SET (
CO-ORD9ATE MEMB]S 7P>ALLEL )! SUBJECT73
= !N NEI W ! T]M /AT$ 2 A PROP]TY ( T (
: X IS /AT$ 6BE A PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47
9ASM* Z ,8S5SI# LIV+ 2+0' IS N A PROP]TY
( ANY (! O!R LIV+ 2+S1 ,89TELLIGI# LIV+
2+0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY ( ,GOD4 ,=
3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF
"S "O OR O!R (! REMA9+ CO-ORD9ATE MEMB]S
7P>ALLEL )! PROP]TY R5D]$7 2 A PROP]TY (
EA* ( ^! CO-ORD9ATE MEMB]S 7P>ALLEL )!
SUBJECT73 = !N ! REMA9+ "O TOO W 2 A
PROP]TY ( T ( : X HAS BE5 /AT$ N 6BE A
PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z X IS A
PROP]TY ( ,8WISDOM0' 6BE ESS5TI,Y ,8!
NATURAL VIRTUE (! R,NAL FACULTY0'1 !N1
TAK+ EA* (! O!R VIRTUES Z WELL 9 ? WAY1
X WD 2 A PROP]TY ( ,8TEMP].E0' 6BE
ESS5TI,Y ,8! NATURAL VIRTUE (! FACULTY (
DESIRE0'4
  ,NEXT1 LOOK F ! PO9T ( VIEW (!
9FLEXIONS1 & SEE1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
IF ! 9FLEXION (! PROP]TY R5D]$ FAILS 6BE
A PROP]TY (! 9FLEXION (! SUBJECT3 = !N
NEI W ! O!R 9FLEXION 2 A PROP]TY (! O!R
9FLEXION4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z
,8B1UTI;LLY0' IS N A PROP]TY (
,8JU/LY0'1 NEI CD ,8B1UTI;L0' 2 A
PROP]TY ( ,8J0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF ! 9FLEXION (!
PROP]TY R5D]$ IS A PROP]TY (! 9FLEXION (
! SUBJECT3 = !N AL ! O!R 9FLEXION W 2 A
PROP]TY (! O!R 9FLEXION4 ,?US 7E4G47
9ASM* Z ,8WALK+ BIP$0' IS A PROP]TY (
MAN1 X WD AL 2 ANY "O'S PROP]TY ,8Z A
MAN0' 6BE DESCRIB$ ,8Z A WALK+ BIP$0'4
,N ONLY 9 ! CASE (! ACTUAL T]M M5;N$ %D
"O LOOK AT ! 9FLEXIONS1 B AL 9 ! CASE (
XS OPPOSITES1 J Z HAS BE5 LAID D[N 9 !
CASE (! =M] -MONPLACE RULES Z WELL40'
,?US1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF !
9FLEXION (! OPPOSITE (! PROP]TY R5D]$
FAILS 6BE ! PROP]TY (! 9FLEXION (!
OPPOSITE (! SUBJECT3 = !N NEI W !
9FLEXION (! O!R OPPOSITE 2 A PROP]TY (!
9FLEXION (! O!R OPPOSITE4 ,?US 7E4G47
9ASM* Z ,8WELL0' IS N A PROP]TY (
,8JU/LY0'1 NEI CD ,8BADLY0' 2 A PROP]TY
( ,8UNJU/LY0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON
! O!R H&1 SEE IF ! 9FLEXION (! OPPOSITE
(! PROP]TY ORIG9,Y SU7E/$ IS A PROP]TY (
! 9FLEXION (! OPPOSITE (! ORIG9AL
SUBJECT3 = !N AL ! 9FLEXION (! O!R
OPPOSITE W 2 A PROP]TY (! 9FLEXION (!
O!R OPPOSITE4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z
,8BE/0' IS A PROP]TY ( ,8! GD0'1
,8WOR/0' AL W 2 A PROP]TY ( ,8! EVIL0'4
                   #G
  ,NEXT1 LOOK F ! PO9T ( VIEW ( ?+S T >E
9 A L REL,N1 & SEE1 = DE/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 IF :AT IS 9 A REL,N L T (!
PROP]TY R5D]$ FAILS 6BE A PROP]TY ( :AT
IS 9 A REL,N L T (! SUBJECT3 = !N NEI W
:AT IS 9 A REL,N L T (! F/ 2 A PROP]TY (
:AT IS 9 A REL,N L T (! SECOND4 ,?US
7E4G47 9ASM* Z ! REL,N (! BUILD] T[>DS !
PRODUC;N (A H\SE IS L T (! DOCTOR T[>DS
! PRODUC;N ( H1L?1 & X IS N A PROP]TY (A
DOCTOR 6PRODUCE H1L?1 X CD N 2 A PROP]TY
(A BUILD] 6PRODUCE A H\SE4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF :AT IS 9 A
REL,N L T (! PROP]TY R5D]$ IS A PROP]TY
( :AT IS 9 A REL,N L T (! SUBJECT3 = !N
AL :AT IS 9 A REL,N L T (! F/ W 2 A
PROP]TY ( :AT IS 9 A REL,N L T (!
SECOND4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z ! REL,N (A
DOCTOR T[>DS ! POSSES.N ( ABIL;Y
6PRODUCE H1L? IS L T (A TRA9] T[>DS !
POSSES.N ( ABIL;Y 6PRODUCE VIG\R1 & X IS
A PROP]TY (A TRA9] 6POSSESS ! ABIL;Y
6PRODUCE VIG\R1 X WD 2 A PROP]TY (A
DOCTOR 6POSSESS ! ABIL;Y 6PRODUCE H1L?4
  ,NEXT LOOK F ! PO9T ( VIEW ( ?+S T >E
ID5TIC,Y RELAT$1 & SEE1 = DE/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 IF ! PR$ICATE T IS ID5TIC,Y
RELAT$ T[>DS TWO SUBJECTS FAILS 6BE A
PROP]TY (! SUBJECT : IS ID5TIC,Y RELAT$
6X Z ! SUBJECT 9 "Q2 = !N NEI W !
PR$ICATE T IS ID5TIC,Y RELAT$ 6BO?
SUBJECTS 2 A PROP]TY (! SUBJECT : IS
ID5TIC,Y RELAT$ 6X Z ! F/4 ,IF1 ON ! O!R
H&1 ! PR$ICATE : IS ID5TIC,Y RELAT$ 6TWO
SUBJECTS IS ! PROP]TY (! SUBJECT : IS
ID5TIC,Y RELAT$ 6X Z ! SUBJECT 9 "Q1 !N
X W N 2 A PROP]TY ( T ( : X HAS BE5 /AT$
6BE A PROP]TY4 7E4G47 9ASM* Z PRUD;E IS
ID5TIC,Y RELAT$ 6BO? ! NO# &! BASE1 S9CE
X IS K ( EA* ( !M1 & X IS N A PROP]TY (
PRUD;E 6BE K (! NO#1 X CD N 2 A PROP]TY
( PRUD;E 6BE K (! BASE4 ,IF1 ON ! O!R
H&1 X IS A PROP]TY ( PRUD;E 6BE ! K (!
NO#1 X CD N 2 A PROP]TY ( X 6BE ! K (!
BASE47' ,= X IS IMPOSSI# =! SAME ?+ 6BE
A PROP]TY ( M ?AN "O SUBJECT4 ,=
3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 ?
-MONPLACE RULE IS ( NO USE3 = :AT IS
,8ID5TIC,Y RELAT$0' IS A S+LE PR$ICATE 9
PROCESS ( -P>ISON ) M ?AN "O SUBJECT4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF !
PR$ICATE QUALIFI$ 0! V]B ,86BE0' FAILS
6BE A PROP]TY (! SUBJECT QUALIFI$ 0! V]B
,86BE0'3 = !N NEI W ! DE/RUC;N (! "O 2 A
PROP]TY (! O!R QUALIFI$ 0! V]B ,86BE
DE/ROY$0'1 NOR W ! ,82COM+'?E "O 2 A
PROP]TY (! O!R QUALIFI$ 0! V]B
,862COME0'4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z X IS N A
PROP]TY ( ,8MAN0' 6BE AN ANIMAL1 NEI CD
X 2 A PROP]TY ( 2COM+ A MAN 62COME AN
ANIMAL2 NOR CD ! DE/RUC;N ( AN ANIMAL 2
A PROP]TY (! DE/RUC;N (A MAN4 ,9 ! SAME
WAY "O %D DERIVE >GU;TS AL F ,82COM+0'
TO ,82+0' & ,82+ DE/ROY$0'1 & F ,82+
DE/ROY$0' TO ,82+0' & TO ,82COM+0'
EXACTLY Z !Y H J BE5 GIV5 F ,82+0' TO
,82COM+0' & ,82+ DE/ROY$0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF ! SUBJECT
SET D[N Z QUALIFI$ 0! V]B ,86BE0' HAS !
PR$ICATE SET D[N Z S QUALIFI$1 Z XS
PROP]TY3 = !N AL ! SUBJECT QUALIFI$ 0! V
,862COME0' W H ! PR$ICATE QUALIFI$ BY
,862COME0' Z XS PROP]TY1 &! SUBJECT
QUALIFI$ 0! V]B 6BE DE/ROY$0' W H Z XS
PROP]TY ! PR$ICATE R5D]$ ) ? QUALIFIC,N4
,?US1 = EXAMPLE1 9ASM* Z X IS A PROP]TY
( MAN 6BE A MORTAL1 X WD 2 A PROP]TY (
2COM+ A MAN 62COME A MORTAL1 &! DE/RUC;N
(A MORTAL WD 2 A PROP]TY (! DE/RUC;N (A
MAN4 ,9 ! SAME WAY "O %D DERIVE >GU;TS
AL F ,82COM+0' & ,82+ DE/ROY$0' BO? TO
,82+0' & 6! 3CLU.NS T FOLL[ F !M1
EXACTLY Z 0 DIRECT$ AL =! PURPOSE (
DE/RUC;N4
  ,NEXT TAKE A LOOK AT ! ,8IDEA0' (!
SUBJECT /AT$1 & SEE1 = DE/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 IF ! SU7E/$ PROP]TY FAILS
62L;G 6! ,8IDEA0' 9 "Q1 OR FAILS 62L;G
6X 9 VIRTUE ( T "* : CAUSES X 6BE> !
DESCRIP;N ( : ! PROP]TY 0 R5D]$3 = !N
:AT HAS BE5 /AT$ 6BE A PROP]TY W N 2 A
PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z ,82+
MO;N.S0' DOES N 2L;G TO ,8MAN-HMF0' QUA
,8MAN0'1 B QUA ,8IDEA0'1 X CD N 2 A
PROP]TY ( ,8MAN0' 6BE MO;N.S4 ,=
3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF
! PROP]TY 9 "Q 2L;GS 6! IDEA1 & 2L;GS 6X
9 T RESPECT 9 VIRTUE ( : "! IS PR$ICAT$
( X T "* ( : ! PR$ICATE 9 "Q HAS BE5
/AT$ N 6BE A PROP]TY3 = !N :AT HAS BE5
/AT$ N 6BE A PROP]TY W 2 A PROP]TY4 ,?US
7E4G47 9ASM* Z X 2L;GS TO ,8LIV+-
CR1TURE-XF0' 6BE -P.D$ ( S\L & BODY1 &
FUR!R ? 2L;GS 6X QUA ,8LIV+-CR1TURE0'1 X
WD 2 A PROP]TY ( ,8LIV+-CR1TURE0' 6BE
-P.D$ ( S\L & BODY4
                   #H
  ,NEXT LOOK F ! PO9T ( VIEW ( GRT] &
LESS DEGREES1 & F/ 7A7 = DE/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 SEE IF :AT IS M-;,P FAILS 6BE
A PROP]TY ( :AT IS M-;,S3 = !N NEI W :AT
IS LESS-;,P 2 A PROP]TY ( :AT IS LESS-
;,S1 NOR L1/-;,P ( L1/-;,S1 NOR MO/-;,P
( MO/-;,S1 NOR ;,P SIMPLY ( ;,S SIMPLY4
,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z 2+ M HI<LY COL\R$ IS
N A PROP]TY ( :AT IS M A BODY1 NEI CD 2+
LESS HI<LY COL\R$ 2 A PROP]TY ( :AT IS
LESS A BODY1 NOR 2+ COL\R$ 2 A PROP]TY (
BODY AT ALL4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON !
O!R H&1 SEE IF :AT IS M-;,P IS A PROP]TY
( :AT IS M-;,S3 = !N AL :AT IS LESS-;,P
W 2 A PROP]TY ( :AT IS LESS ;,S1 & L1/-
;,P ( L1/-;,S1 & MO/-;,P ( MO/-;,S1 &
;,P SIMPLY ( ;,S SIMPLY4 ,?US 7E4G47
9ASM* Z A HI<] DEGREE ( S5S,N IS A
PROP]TY (A HI<] DEGREE ( LIFE1 A L[]
DEGREE ( S5S,N AL WD 2 A PROP]TY (A L[]
DEGREE ( LIFE1 &! HI<E/ (! HI<E/ &! L[E/
(! L[E/ DEGREE1 & S5S,N SIMPLY ( LIFE
SIMPLY4
  ,AL Y %D LOOK AT ! >GU;T F A SIMPLE
PR$IC,N 6! SAME QUALIFI$ TYPES (
PR$IC,N1 & SEE1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
IF ;,P SIMPLY FAILS 6BE A PROP]TY ( ;,S
SIMPLY2 = !N NEI W M-;,P 2 A PROP]TY (
M-;,S1 NOR LESS-;,P ( LESS-;,S1 NOR MO/-
;,P ( MO/-;,S1 NOR L1/-;,P ( L1/-,S4
,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z ,8VIRTU\S0' IS N A
PROP]TY ( ,8MAN0'1 NEI CD ,8M VIRTU\S0'
2 A PROP]TY ( :AT IS ,8M HUMAN0'4 ,=
3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF
;,P SIMPLY IS A PROP]TY ( ;,S SIMPLY3 =
!N M ;,P AL W 2 A PROP]TY ( M-;,S1 &
LESS-;,P ( LESS-;,S1 & L1/-;,P ( L1/-
;,S1 & MO/-;,P ( MO/-,S4 ,?US 7E4G47 A
T5D5CY 6MOVE UPW>DS 0NATURE IS A PROP]TY
( FIRE1 & S AL A GRT] T5D5CY 6MOVE
UPW>DS 0NATURE WD 2 A PROP]TY ( :AT IS M
FI]Y4 ,9 ! SAME WAY TOO "O %D LOOK AT
ALL ^! MATT]S F ! PO9T ( VIEW (! O!RS Z
WELL4
  ,SECONDLY 7B7 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
SEE IF ! M LIKELY PROP]TY FAILS 6BE A
PROP]TY (! M LIKELY SUBJECT3 = !N NEI W
! LESS LIKELY PROP]TY 2 A PROP]TY (!
LESS LIKELY SUBJECT4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z
,8P]CVG0' IS M LIKELY 6BE A PROP]TY (
,8ANIMAL0' ?AN ,8"K+0' ( ,8MAN0'1 &
,8P]CVG0' IS N A PROP]TY ( ,8ANIMAL0'1
,8"K+0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY ( ,8MAN0'4 ,=
3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF
! LESS LIKELY PROP]TY IS A PROP]TY (!
LESS LIKELY SUBJECT2 = !N TOO ! M LIKELY
PROP]TY W 2 A PROP]TY (! M LIKELY
SUBJECT4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z ,86BE
NATUR,Y CIVILIZ$0' IS LESS LIKELY 6BE A
PROP]TY ( MAN ?AN ,86LIVE0' ( AN ANIMAL1
& X IS A PROP]TY ( MAN 6BE NATUR,Y
CIVILIZ$1 X WD 2 A PROP]TY ( ANIMAL
6LIVE4
  ,?IRDLY 7C7 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE
IF ! PR$ICATE FAILS 6BE A PROP]TY ( T (
: X IS M LIKELY 6BE A PROP]TY3 = !N NEI
W X 2 A PROP]TY ( T ( : X IS LESS LIKELY
6BE A PROP]TY3 :ILE IF X IS A PROP]TY (!
=M]1 X W N 2 A PROP]TY (! LATT]4 ,?US
7E4G47 9ASM* Z ,86BE COL\R$0' IS M
LIKELY 6BE A PROP]TY (A ,8SURFACE0' ?AN
(A ,8BODY0'1 & X IS N A PROP]TY (A
SURFACE1 ,86BE COL\R$0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY
( ,8BODY0'2 :ILE IF X IS A PROP]TY (A
,8SURFACE0'1 X CD N 2 A PROP]TY (A
,8BODY0'4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON !
O!R H&1 ? -MONPLACE RULE IS N ( ANY USE3
= X IS IMPOSSI# =! SAME ?+ 6BE A PROP]TY
( M ?AN "O ?+4
  ,F\R?LY 7D7 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE
IF :AT IS M LIKELY 6BE A PROP]TY (A GIV5
SUBJECT FAILS 6BE XS PROP]TY3 = !N NEI W
:AT IS LESS LIKELY 6BE A PROP]TY ( X 2
XS PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z
,8S5SI#0' IS M LIKELY ?AN ,8DIVISI#0'
6BE A PROP]TY ( ,8ANIMAL0'1 & ,8S5SI#0'
IS N A PROP]TY ( ANIMAL1 ,8DIVISI#0' CD
N 2 A PROP]TY ( ANIMAL4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF :AT IS
LESS LIKELY 6BE A PROP]TY ( X IS A
PROP]TY2 = !N :AT IS M LIKELY 6BE A
PROP]TY ( X W 2 A PROP]TY Z WELL4 ,?US1
= EXAMPLE1 9ASM* Z ,8S5S,N0' IS LESS
LIKELY 6BE A PROP]TY ( ,8ANIMAL0' ?AN
LIFE0'1 & ,8S5S,N0' IS A PROP]TY (
ANIMAL1 ,8LIFE0' WD 2 A PROP]TY (
ANIMAL4
  ,NEXT1 LOOK F ! PO9T ( VIEW (!
ATTRIBUTES T 2L;G 9 A L MANN]1 & F/ 7A7
= DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF :AT IS Z
M* A PROP]TY FAILS 6BE A PROP]TY ( T ( :
X IS Z M* A PROP]TY3 = !N NEI W T : IS Z
M* A PROP]TY Z X 2 A PROP]TY ( T ( : X
IS Z M* A PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z
,8DESIR+0' IS Z M* A PROP]TY (! FACULTY
( DESIRE Z R1SON+0' IS A PROP]TY (!
FACULTY ( R1SON1 & DESIR+ IS N A PROP]TY
(! FACULTY ( DESIRE1 R1SON+ CD N 2 A
PROP]TY (! FACULTY ( R1SON4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE
PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE IF :AT IS Z
M* A PROP]TY IS A PROP]TY ( T ( : X IS Z
M* A PROP]TY3 = !N AL :AT IS Z M* A
PROP]TY Z X W 2 A PROP]TY ( T ( : X IS Z
M* A PROP]TY4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z X IS Z
M* A PROP]TY ( ,8! FACULTY ( R1SON0' 6BE
,8! PRIM>Y S1T ( WISDOM0' Z X IS ( ,8!
FACULTY ( DESIRE0' 6BE ,8! PRIM>Y S1T (
TEMP].E0'1 & X IS A PROP]TY (! FACULTY (
R1SON 6BE ! PRIM>Y S1T ( WISDOM1 X WD 2
A PROP]TY (! FACULTY ( DESIRE 6BE !
PRIM>Y S1T ( TEMP].E4
  ,SECONDLY 7B7 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1
SEE IF :AT IS Z M* A PROP]TY ( ANY?+
FAILS 6BE A PROP]TY ( X3 = !N NEI W :AT
IS Z M* A PROP]TY 2 A PROP]TY ( X4 ,?US
7E4G47 9ASM* Z ,8SEE+0' IS Z M* A
PROP]TY ( MAN Z ,8HE>+0'1 & ,8SEE+0' IS
N A PROP]TY ( MAN1 ,8HE>+0' CD N 2 A
PROP]TY ( MAN4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON
! O!R H&1 SEE IF :AT IS Z M* A PROP]TY (
X IS XS PROP]TY3 = !N :AT IS Z M* A
PROP]TY ( X Z ! =M] W 2 XS PROP]TY Z
WELL4 ,?US 7E4G47 X IS Z M* A PROP]TY (!
S\L 6BE ! PRIM>Y POSSESSOR (A "P T
DESIRES Z (A "P T R1SONS1 & X IS A
PROP]TY (! S\L 6BE ! PRIM>Y POSSESSOR (A
"P T DESIRES1 & S X 2 A PROP]TY (! S\L
6BE ! PRIM>Y POSSESSOR (A "P T R1SONS4
  ,?IRDLY 7C7 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE
IF X FAILS 6BE A PROP]TY ( T ( : X IS Z
M* A PROP]TY3 = !N NEI W X 2 A PROP]TY (
T ( : X IS Z M* A PROP]TY Z (! =M]1 :ILE
IF X 2 A PROP]TY (! =M]1 X W N 2 A
PROP]TY (! O!R4 ,?US 7E4G47 9ASM* Z
,86BURN0' IS Z M* A PROP]TY ( ,8FLAME0'
Z ( ,8LIVE COALS0'1 & ,86BURN0' IS N A
PROP]TY ( FLAME1 ,86BURN0' CD N 2 A
PROP]TY ( LIVE COALS3 :ILE IF X IS A
PROP]TY ( FLAME1 X CD N 2 A PROP]TY (
LIVE COALS4 ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON !
O!R H&1 ? -MONPLACE RULE IS ( NO USE4
  ,! RULE BAS$ ON ?+S T >E 9 A L REL,N0'
DI6]S F ! RULE BAS$ ON ATTRIBUTES T 2L;G
9 A L MANN]10' 2C ! =M] PO9T IS SECUR$
0ANALOGY1 N F REFLEC;N ON ! 2L;G+ ( ANY
ATTRIBUTE1 :ILE ! LATT] IS JUDG$ 0A
-P>ISON BAS$ ON ! FACT T AN ATTRIBUTE
2L;GS4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF 9
R5D]+ ! PROP]TY POT5TI,Y1 HE HAS AL "? T
POT5TIAL;Y R5D]$ ! PROP]TY RELATIVELY
6"S?+ T DOES N EXI/1 :5 ! POT5TIAL;Y 9
"Q _C 2L;G 6:AT DOES N EXI/3 = !N :AT IS
/AT$ 6BE A PROP]TY W N 2 A PROP]TY4 ,?US
7E4G47 HE :O HAS SD T ,8BR1?A#0' IS A
PROP]TY ( ,8AIR0' HAS1 ON ! "O H&1 R5D]$
! PROP]TY POT5TI,Y 7= T IS ,8BR1?A#0' :
IS S* Z C 2 BR1!D71 & ON ! O!R H& HAS AL
R5D]$ ! PROP]TY RELATIVELY 6:AT DOES N
EXI/3-= :ILE AIR MAY EXI/1 EV5 ?\< "!
EXI/ NO ANIMAL S 3/ITUT$ Z 6BR1! ! AIR1
X IS N POSSI# 6BR1! X IF NO ANIMAL EXI/3
S T X W N1 EI1 2 A PROP]TY ( AIR 6BE S*
Z C 2 BR1!D AT A "T :5 "! EXI/S NO
ANIMAL S* Z 6BR1! X & S X FOLL[S T
,8BR1?A#0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY ( AIR4
  ,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF 9 R5D]+
! PROP]TY POT5TI,Y HE R5D]S ! PROP]TY EI
RELATIVELY 6"S?+ T EXI/S1 OR 6"S?+ T
DOES N EXI/1 :5 ! POT5TIAL;Y 9 "Q C 2L;G
6:AT DOES N EXI/3 = !N :AT HAS BE5 /AT$
N 6BE A PROP]TY W 2 A PROP]TY4 ,?US
E4G47 HE :O R5D]S X Z A PROP]TY ( ,82+0'
6BE ,8CAPA# ( 2+ ACT$ ^U OR ( ACT+0'1 9
R5D]+ ! PROP]TY POT5TI,Y1 HAS R5D]$ !
PROP]TY RELATIVELY 6"S?+ T EXI/S3 = :5
,82+0' EXI/S1 X W AL 2 CAPA# ( 2+ ACT$
^U OR ( ACT+ 9 A C]TA9 WAY3 S T 6BE
,8CAPA# ( 2+ ACT$ ^U OR ( ACT+0' WD 2 A
PROP]TY ( ,82+0'4
  ,NEXT1 = DE/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 SEE IF
HE HAS /AT$ ! PROP]TY 9 ! SUP]LATIVE3 =
!N :AT HAS BE5 /AT$ 6BE A PROP]TY W N 2
A PROP]TY4 ,= P :O R5D] ! PROP]TY 9 T
WAY F9D T (! OBJECT ( : ! DESCRIP;N IS
TRUE1 ! "N IS N TRUE Z WELL3 = ?\< !
OBJECT P]I% ! DESCRIP;N W 3T9UE 9 2+ N"O
! LESS2 = X 2L;GS MO/ NE>LY 6"S?+ T IS 9
2+4 ,AN EXAMPLE WD 2 SUPPOS+ ANY "O 7
6R5D] ,8! LI<TE/ BODY0' Z A PROP]TY (
,8FIRE0'3 =1 ?\< FIRE P]I%1 "! EH RE W /
2 "S =M ( BODY T IS ! LI<TE/1 S T ,8!
LI<TE/ BODY0' CD N 2 A PROP]TY ( FIRE4
,= 3/RUCTIVE PURPOSES1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEE
IF HE HAS AVOID$ R5D]+ ! PROP]TY 9 !
SUP]LATIVE3 = !N ! PROP]TY W 9 ? RESPECT
H BE5 PROP]TY ( MAN HAS N R5D]$ !
PROP]TY CORRECTLY /AT$4 ,?US 7E4G47
9ASM* Z HE 9 ! SUP]LATIVE1 ! PROP]TY WD
9 :O /ATES 'A NATUR,Y CIVILIZ$ ANIMAL0'
Z A ? RESPECT H BE5 CORRECTLY /AT$4

