
    ,A ,,REVIEW
  ,TWO REM>KA# BOOKS >E ,<5T'S 8,\R
,2NEVOL5T ,FEUDALISM0 LEFT-BRACE #G"R-
BRACE & ,BROOKS'S 8,! ,SOCIAL ,UNRE/40
LEFT-BRACE #H"R-BRACE ,9 ^! TWO BOOKS !
OPPOSITE SIDES (! LABOR PRO#M >E EXP.D$1
EA* WRIT] DEVOT+ HMF ) APPREH5.N 6! SIDE
HE FE>S & VIEWS ) 4FAVOR4 ,X WD APPE> T
!Y H SET !MVS ! TASK ( COLLAT+1 Z A
W>N+1 ! PH5OM5A ( TWO C.T] SOCIAL =CES4
,MR4 ,<5T1 :O IS SYMPA!TIC )! SOCIALI/
MOVE;T1 FOLL[S ) CYNIC FE> E A7RESSIVE
ACT (! CAPITALI/ CLASS4 ,MR4 ,BROOKS1 :O
YE>NS =! P]PETU,N (! CAPITALI/ SY/EM Z
L;G Z POSSI#1 FOLL[S ) GRAVE 4MAY EA*
A7RESSIVE ACT (! LABOR & SOCIALI/
ORGANIZ,NS4 ,MR4 ,<5T TRACES ! EMASCUL,N
( LABOR 0CAPITAL1 & ,MR4 ,BROOKS TRACES
! EMASCUL,N ( 9DEP5D5T -PET+ CAPITAL
0LABOR4 ,9 %ORT1 EA* M>%ALS ! FACTS (A
SIDE 9 ! TWO SIDES : G 6MAKE A /RU7LE S
GRT T EV5 ! ,FR5* ,REVOLU;N IS
9SIGNIFICANT 2S X2 = ? LAT] /RU7LE1 =!
F/ "T 9 ! HI/ORY ( /RU7LES1 IS N 3F9$
6ANY "PICUL> POR;N (! GLOBE1 B 9VOLVES !
:OLE ( X4
  ,/>T+ ON ! ASSUMP;N T SOCIETY IS AT
PRES5T 9 A /ATE ( FLUX1 ,MR4 ,<5T SEES X
RAPIDLY CRY/ALLIZ+ 96A /ATUS : C BE/ 2
DESCRIB$ Z "S?+ 9 ! NATURE (A 2NEVOL5T
FEUDALISM4 ,HE LAU<S 6SCORN ANY IMM
R1LIZ,N (! ,M>XIAN DR1M1 :ILE ,TOL/OYAN
UTOPIAS & ,KROPOTK9IAN -MUNI/IC UNIONS (
%OP & F>M >E TOO WILD 6M]IT 3SID],N4 ,!
-+ /ATUS : ,MR4 ,<5T DEPICTS IS A CLASS
DOM9,N 0! CAPITALI/S4 ,LABOR W TAKE XS
DEF9ITE PLACE Z A DEP5D5T CLASS1 LIV+ 9
A 3DI;N ( MA*9E S]VITUDE FAIRLY ANALOG\S
6! L& S]VITUDE (! ,MI4LE ,AGES4 ,T IS
6SAY1 LABOR W 2 B.D 6! MA*9E1 ?\< LESS
H>%LY1 9 FA%ION "S:AT SIMIL> 6T 9 : !
E>LI] S]F 0 B.D 6! SOIL4 ,Z HE SAYS1
8,BONDAGE 6! L& 0 ! BASIS ( VILLE9AGE 9
! OLD REGIME2 BONDAGE 6! JOB W 2 ! BASIS
( VILLE9AGE 9 ! NEW40
  ,AT ! TOP (! NEW SOCIETY W T[] !
MAGNATE1 ! NEW FEUDAL B>ON2 AT ! BOTTOM
W 2 F.D ! WA/RELS &! 9E6ICI5TS4 ,! NEW
SOCIETY HE GRADES Z FOLL[S3
  8,I4 ,! B>ONS1 GRAD$ ON ! BASIS (
POSSES.NS4
  8,,II4 ,! C\RT AG5TS & RETA9]S4 7,?
CLASS W 9CLUDE ! $ITORS ( ,8RESPECTA#0'
& ,8SAFE0' NEWSPAP]S1 ! PA/ORS (
,83S]VATIVE0' & ,8W1L?Y0' *UR*ES1 !
PROFESSORS & T1*]S 9 5D[$ COLLEGES &
S*OOLS1 LAWY]S G5],Y1 & MO/ JUDGES &
POLITICIANS74
  8,,III4 ,! "W]S 9 PURE & APPLI$ SCI;E1
>TI/S1 & PHYSICIANS4
  8,,IV4 ,! 5TREPR5EURS1 ! MANAG]S (!
GRT 9DU/RIES1 TRANS=M$ 96A SAL>I$ CLASS4
  8,V4 ,! =EM5 & SUP]9T5D5TS4 ,? CLASS
HAS "HTO=E BE5 RECRUIT$ L>GELY F !
SKILL$ "W]S1 B )! GR[? ( TE*NICAL $UC,N
9 S*OOLS & COLLEGES1 &! DEVELOP;T ( FIX$
CA/E1 X IS LIKELY 62COME 5TIRELY
DI6]5TIAT$4
  8,,VI4 ,! VILLE9S (! CITIES & T[NS1 M
OR LESS REGUL>LY EMPLOY$1 :O D SKILL$ "W
& >E "PI,Y PROTECT$ 0ORGANIZ,N4
  8,,VII4 ,! VILLE9S (! CITIES & T[NS :O
D UNSKILL$ "W & >E UNPROTECT$
0ORGANIZ,N4 ,!Y W -PRISE ! LABOR]S1
DOME/ICS1 & CL]KS4
  8,,VIII4 ,! VILLE9S (! MANORIAL
E/ATES1 (! GRT F>MS1 ! M9ES1 &! =E/S4
  8,,IX4 ,! SMALL-UNIT F>M]S 7L&-[N+71 !
PETTY TRADESM51 & MANUFACTUR]S4
  8,X4 ,! SUBT5ANTS (! MANORIAL E/ATES &
GRT F>MS 7CORRESPOND+ 6! CLASS ( ,8FREE
T5ANTS0' 9 ! OLD ,FEUDALISM74
  8,,XI4 ,! COTT]S4
  8,,XII4 ,! TRAMPS1 ! O3A.N,Y EMPLOY$1
! UNEMPLOY$--! WA/RELS (! C;Y & C.TRY40
  8,! NEW ,FEUDALISM1 L MO/ AUTOCRACIES1
W FO/] N ONLY ! >TS1 B AL C]TA9 K9DS (
LE>N+--"PICUL>LY ! K9DS : >E UNLIKELY
64TURB ! M9DS (! MULTITUDE4 ,A FUTURE
,M>%1 OR ,COPE1 OR ,LE ,-TE W 2 LIB],Y
PATRONIZ$ & LEFT FREE 64COV] :AT HE W2 &
S1 TOO1 AN ,$ISON OR A ,M>CONI4 ,ONLY !Y
M/ N M$DLE ) ANY?+ RELAT+ 6SOCIAL
SCI;E40
  ,X M/ 2 3FESS$ T ,MR4 ,<5T'S >GU;TS >E
CUNN+LY 3TRIV$ & >RAY$4 ,!Y M/ 2 R1D 6BE
APPRECIAT$4 ,Z AN EXAMPLE ( 8 /YLE1 : AT
! SAME "T G5]ALIZES A POR;N ( 8 >GU;T1 !
FOLL[+ MAY WELL 2 GIV53
  8,! NEW ,FEUDALISM W 2 B AN ORD]LY
\TGR[? ( PRES5T T5D5CIES & 3DI;NS4 ,ALL
SOCIETIES EVOLVE NATUR,Y \ ( _!
PR$ECESSORS4 ,9 SOCIOLOGY1 Z 9 BIOLOGY1
"! IS NO CELL
)\T A P>5T CELL4 ,! SOCIETY ( EA* G5],N
DEVELOPS A MULTITUDE ( SPONTANE\S &
ACQUIR$ V>I,NS1 & \ ( ^!1 0A BL5D+
PROCESS ( NATURAL & 3SCI\S SELEC;N1 !
SU3E$+ SOCIETY IS EVOLV$4 ,! NEW ORD] W
DI6] 9 NO IMPORTANT RESPECTS F ! PRES5T1
EXCEPT 9 ! -PLET] DEVELOP;T ( XS M
SALI5T F1TURES4 ,! VISITOR F ANO!R
PLANET :O _H "KN ! OLD & %D SEE ! NEW WD
NOTE B FEW *ANGES4 ,ALT] ET ,IDEM--ANO!R
YET ! SAME--HE WD SAY4 ,F MAGNATE 6B>ON1
F "WMAN 6VILLE91 F PUBLICI/ 6C\RT AG5T &
RETA9]1 W 2 *ANGES ( /ATE & FUNC;N S
SLI<T Z 6ELUDE ALL B ! KE5E/ EYES40
  ,& 9 3CLU.N1 6%[ H[ 2NEVOL5T & B1UTI;L
? NEW FEUDALISM ( \RS W BE1 ,MR4 ,<5T
SAYS3 8,P1CE & /ABIL;Y X W MA9TA9 AT ALL
HAZ>DS2 &! MASS1 REMEMB]+ ! *AOS1 !
TURMOIL1 ! 9SECUR;Y (! PA/1 W B.S XS
REIGN4 4 4 ,E6ICI5CY--! FACULTY ( GETT+
?+S--IS AT LA/ REW>D$ Z X %D BE1 =!
E6ICI5T H 9H]IT$ ! E>? & XS FUL;S4 ,!
L[LY1 ^: HAPPI;S IS GRT] & ^: WELF>E IS
M ?OR\<LY 3S]V$ :5 GOV]N$ ?AN :5 GOV]N+1
Z A TW5TIE?-C5TURY PHILOSOPH] SD ( !M1
>E SETTL$ & HAPPY 9 ! /ATE : R1SON &
EXP]I;E T1* IS _! ,GOD-APPO9T$ LOT4 ,!Y
>E -=TA# TOO2 & IF ! PATRI>*AL ID1L (A
V9E & FIG TREE = EA* IS N YET ATTA9$1 AT
L1/ EA* HAS 8 R5T$ PAT* 9 ! C.TRY OR 8
R5T$ CELL 9 A C;Y BUILD+4 ,BR1D &!
CIRCUS >E FREELY GIV5 6! DES]V+1 & Z =!
UNDES]V+1 !Y >E M]ELY R1P+ ! REW>DS ( _!
3TUMACY & PRIDE4 ,ORD] REIGNS1 EA* HAS 8
JU/LY APPO9T$ %>E1 &! /ATE RE/S1 9
SECUR;Y1 ,8LAPT 9 UNIV]SAL LAW40'0
  ,MR4 ,BROOKS1 ON ! O!R H&1 SEES RIS+ &
4SOLV+ & RIS+ AG 9 ! SOCIAL FLUX ! OM9\S
=MS (A NEW SOCIETY : IS ! DIRECT
ANTI!SIS (A 2NEVOL5T FEUDALISM4 ,HE
TREM#S AT ! RA% 9TREPID;Y (! CAPITALI/S
:O FI<T ! LABOR UNIONS1 = 0S* RA%;S HE
GRTLY FE>S T LABOR W 2 DRIV5 6EXPRESS XS
AIMS & /R5G? 9 POLITICAL T]MS1 : T]MS W
9EVITABLY 2 SOCIALI/IC T]MS4
  ,6KEEP D[N ! RIS+ TIDE ( SOCIALISM1 HE
PR1*ES GRT] MEEK;S & 2NEVOL;E 6!
CAPITALI/S4 ,NO L;G] MAY !Y CLAIM ! "R
6RUN _! [N BUSI;S1 6B1T D[N ! LABOR]'S
/&>D ( LIV+ =! SAKE ( 9CR1S$ PR(ITS1
6DICTATE T]MS ( EMPLOY;T 69DIVIDUAL
"W]S1 6WAX "RE\SLY 9DIGNANT :5 ORGANIZ$
LABOR TAKES A H& 9 _! BUSI;S4 ,NO L;G]
MAY ! CAPITALI/ SAY 8MY0 BUSI;S1 OR EV5
?9K 8MY0 BUSI;S2 HE M/ SAY 8\R0 BUSI;S1
& ?9K 8\R0 BUSI;S Z WELL1 A3EPT+ LABOR Z
A "PN] ^: VOICE M/ 2 HE>D4 ,& IF !
CAPITALI/S D N 2COME M MEEK & 2NEVOL5T 9
_! D1L+S ) LABOR1 LABOR W 2 ANTAGONIZ$ &
W PROCE$ 6WR1K T]RI# POLITICAL V5GE.E1
&! PRES5T SOCIAL FLUX W H>D5 96A /ATUS (
SOCIALISM4
  ,MR4 ,BROOKS DR1MS (A SOCIETY AT :
,MR4 ,<5T SNE]S Z 8A SLI<TLY MODIFI$
9DIVIDUALISM1 ":9 EA* UNIT SECURES ! J
REW>D ( 8 CAPAC;Y & S]VICE40 ,6ATTA9 ?
HAPPY /ATE1 ,MR4 ,BROOKS IMPOSES
CIRCUMSPEC;N ^U ! CAPITALI/S 9 _! REL,NS
) LABOR4 8,IF ! SOCIALI/IC _S IS 6BE
HELD 9 ABEY.E 9 ? C.TRY1 BUSI;SES ( ? "*
7AN?RACITE COAL M9+7 M/ 2 H&L$ )
EXTRAORD9>Y CAU;N40 ,: IS 6SAY1 T 6)/& !
ADV.E ( SOCIALISM1 A GRT & GRT] M1SURE (
,MR4 ,<5T'S ,,2NEVOL;E W 2 REQUIR$4
  ,AG & AG1 ,MR4 ,BROOKS REIT]ATES !
DANG] HE SEES 9 H>%LY TR1T+ LABOR4 8,X
IS N PROBA# T EMPLOY]S C DE/ROY UNIONISM
9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES4 ,ADROIT & DESP]ATE
ATTEMPTS W1 H["E1 2 MADE1 IF WE M1N
0UNIONISM ! UNDISCIPL9$ & A7RESSIVE FACT
( VIGOR\S & DET]M9$ ORGANIZ,NS4 ,IF
CAPITAL %D PROVE TOO /R;G 9 ? /RU7LE1 !
RESULT IS EASY 6PREDICT4 ,! EMPLOY]S H
ONLY 63V9CE ORGANIZ$ LABOR T X _C HOLD
XS [N AG/ ! CAPITALI/ MANAG]1 &! :OLE
5]GY T N[ GOES 6! UNION W TURN 6AN
A7RESSIVE POLITICAL SOCIALISM4 ,X W N 2
! H>M.S SYMPA?Y ) 9CR1S$ C;Y & /ATE
FUNC;NS : TRADE UNIONS ALR FEEL2 X W
2COME A TURBUL5T POLITICAL =CE B5T ^U
US+ E W1PON ( TAX,N AG/ ! RI*40
  8,! MO/ 3CRETE IMPULSE T N[ FAVORS
SOCIALISM 9 ? C.TRY IS ! 9SANE PURPOSE
6DEPRIVE LABOR ORGANIZ,NS (! FULL &
-PLETE "RS T G ) F$]AT$ UNIONISM40
  8,T : T1*ES A UNION T X _C SU3E$ Z A
UNION TURNS X T[>D SOCIALISM4 ,9 L;G
/RIKES 9 T[NS L ,M>LBORO & ,BROOKFIELD
/R;G UNIONS >E DEF1T$4 ,HUNDR$S ( M5
L1VE ^! T[NS = %OE-C5TRES L ,BROCKTON1
": !Y >E N[ VOT+ ! SOCIALI/ TICKET4 ,!
SOCIALI/ MAYOR ( ? C;Y TELLS ME1 ,8,! M5
:O -E 6U N[ F T[NS ": !Y H BE5 ?OR\<LY
:IPP$ 9 A /RIKE >E AM;G \R MO/ ACTIVE
"W+ SOCIALI/S40' ,! BITT];S 5G5D]$ 0?
S5SE ( DEF1T IS TURN$ 6POLITICS1 Z X W
"?\T ! :OLE C.TRY1 IF ORGANIZ,N ( LABOR
IS DEPRIV$ ( XS "RS40
  8,? 5M;Y ( CAPITAL 6! TRADE UNION IS
WAT*$ ) GLEE 0E 9TELLIG5T SOCIALI/ 9 \R
MID/4 ,E UNION T IS B1T5 OR 4C\RAG$ 9 XS
/RU7LE IS RIP5+ FRUIT = SOCIALISM40
  8,! R1L P]IL : WE N[ FACE IS ! ?R1T (A
CLASS 3FLICT4 ,IF CAPITALISM 9SI/S ^U !
POLICY ( \TRAG+ ! SAV+ ASPIR,N (!
,AM]ICAN "WMAN 6RAISE 8 /&>D ( -=T
& LEISURE1 E ELE;T ( CLASS 3FLICT W
/R5G!N AM;G U40
  8,WE H ONLY 6HUMILIATE :AT IS BE/ 9 !
TRADE UNION1 & !N E WOR/ F1TURE (
SOCIALISM IS FA/5$ ^U U40
  ,? /R;G T5D5CY 9 ! RANKS (! "W]S T[>D
SOCIALISM IS :AT ,MR4 ,BROOKS "*IZES !
8SOCIAL UNRE/02 & HE HOPES 6SEE !
,REPUBLICAN1 ! ,CLEVEL& ,DEMOCRAT1 &!
3S]VATIVE & L>GE PROP]TY 9T]E/S 8B& TGR
AG/ ? -MON FOE10 : IS SOCIALISM4 ,& HE
IS N ABV FEEL+ GRAVE & WELL-3TA9$
SATISFAC;N :]"E ! SOCIALI/ DOCTR9AIRE
HAS BE5 3TRADICT$ 0M5 ATTEMPT+ 6PRACTISE
COOP],N 9 ! MID/ (! -PETITIVE SY/EM1 Z 9
,BELGIUM4
  ,N"E!.S1 HE CAT*ES FLEET+ GLIMPSES (
AN EXTREME & TYRANNIC,Y 2NEVOL5T
FEUDALISM V L 6,MR4 ,<5T'S1 Z WIT;S !
FOLL[+3
  8,I ASK$ "O (! L>GE/ EMPLOY]S ( LABOR
9 ! ,S\? IF HE FE>$ ! -+ (! TRADE UNION4
,8,NO10' HE SD1 ,8X IS "O GD RESULT (
RACE PREJUDICE1 T ! NEGRO W 5A# U 9 !
L;G RUN 6W1K5 ! TRADE UNION S T X _C H>M
U4 ,WE C KEEP WAGES D[N )! NEGRO & WE C
PREV5T TOO M* ORGANIZ,N40'
  8,X IS 9 ? _S T ! L[] /&>DS >E 6BE
US$4 ,IF ? PURPOSE %D SU3E$1 X HAS B "O
ISSUE1--! IMM5SE /R5G!N+ (A PLUTOCRATIC
ADM9I/R,N AT ! TOP1 S]V$ 0AN >MY ( HI<-
SAL>I$ HELP]S1 ) AN ELITE ( SKILL$ &
WELL-PD "WM51 B ALL RE/+ ON :AT WD
ESS5TI,Y 2 A S]F CLASS ( L[-PD LABOR & ?
MASS KEPT 9 ORD] 0AN 9CR1S$ USE (
MILIT>Y =CE40
  ,9 BRIEF SUMM>Y ( ^! TWO NOTA# BOOKS1
X MAY 2 SD T ,MR4 ,<5T IS AL>M$1 7?\< HE
DOES N FLATLY SAY S71 AT ! TOO GRT
SOCIAL RE/;L;S 9 ! -MUN;Y1 : IS P]MITT+
! CAPITALI/S 6=M ! NEW SOCIETY 6_! LIK+2
& T ,MR4 ,BROOKS IS AL>M$1 7& HE FLATLY
SAYS S71 AT ! SOCIAL UNRE/ : ?R1T5S !
MODIFI$ 9DIVIDUALISM 96: HE WD L 6SEE
SOCIETY EVOLVE4 ,MR4 ,<5T 2HOLDS !
CAPITALI/ CLASS RIS+ 6DOM9ATE ! /ATE &!
"W+ CLASS2 ,MR4 ,BROOKS 2HOLDS ! "W+
CLASS RIS+ 6DOM9ATE ! /ATE &! CAPITALI/
CLASS4 ,"O FE>S ! PAT]NALISM (A CLASS2 !
O!R1 ! TYRANNY (! MASS4




